The Toyota Highlander has been a mainstay in the mid-size SUV market for over two decades, consistently earning praise for its reliability, practicality, and family-friendly features. With so many model years to choose from, deciding which Highlander is the “best” can be a daunting task. This article will delve into the various generations and model years, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses to help you make an informed decision. We’ll examine performance, features, reliability, and overall value to determine which Highlander truly stands out.
The First Generation (2001-2007): Setting the Stage
The first generation Highlander arrived in 2001, offering a comfortable and car-like alternative to traditional truck-based SUVs. It quickly gained popularity for its smooth ride, spacious interior, and available V6 engine.
2001-2003: Early Successes and Minor Refinements
These early models established the Highlander’s reputation for reliability. The 2001 model, while a debut, offered a solid foundation. The 2002 and 2003 versions saw minor improvements in features and refinement. A key feature to consider is the available all-wheel drive system, which provided enhanced traction in various weather conditions. Early Highlanders are generally more affordable but may lack some of the modern tech features found in later models.
2004-2007: Mid-Cycle Refresh and Enhanced Safety
The 2004 model year brought a significant mid-cycle refresh, including updated styling, improved safety features, and a more powerful V6 engine. These later first-generation models are often considered more desirable due to these enhancements. The addition of side curtain airbags further improved passenger safety. This generation is a great choice for those seeking a reliable and practical SUV on a budget.
The Second Generation (2008-2013): Growing Up and Moving Forward
The second generation Highlander was larger and more refined than its predecessor, offering more interior space and a more comfortable ride. It also introduced new features and technologies, further solidifying its position in the competitive mid-size SUV segment.
2008-2010: Increased Size and Enhanced Comfort
The 2008 Highlander marked a significant step forward in terms of size and refinement. It offered a more spacious third row and a smoother ride. The interior design was also updated, providing a more modern and comfortable environment. These models are a good choice for families needing extra space. Consider the trim levels carefully, as features varied significantly.
2011-2013: Refreshed Styling and Improved Fuel Economy
The 2011 model year brought a refreshed exterior design and improved fuel economy thanks to engine enhancements. These later second-generation models are often considered the sweet spot for balancing features, reliability, and value. The updated infotainment system also added to the overall appeal. The 2011-2013 Highlanders offer a noticeable improvement in fuel efficiency compared to earlier models.
The Third Generation (2014-2019): Modern Features and Hybrid Options
The third generation Highlander brought a more modern design, advanced safety features, and a focus on fuel efficiency. It also offered a hybrid variant, appealing to environmentally conscious buyers.
2014-2016: Bold Design and Advanced Technology
The 2014 Highlander introduced a bolder exterior design and a more upscale interior. It also featured advanced safety technologies such as adaptive cruise control and lane departure warning, depending on the trim level. These models represent a significant step up in terms of technology and safety features. The ride quality was also improved, making it a comfortable choice for long road trips.
2017-2019: Mid-Cycle Refresh and Enhanced Performance
The 2017 model year brought a mid-cycle refresh, including updated styling, a more powerful V6 engine, and an eight-speed automatic transmission. These later third-generation models are highly sought after due to their enhanced performance and updated features. The updated transmission improved both fuel economy and acceleration. The 2017-2019 Highlanders are arguably the most desirable of the third generation.
The Fourth Generation (2020-Present): Contemporary Design and Hybrid Dominance
The fourth generation Highlander boasts a sophisticated design, a refined interior, and a strong emphasis on hybrid powertrains. It continues to offer a comfortable and practical driving experience, making it a top contender in the mid-size SUV market.
2020-2022: New Platform and Hybrid Advancements
The 2020 Highlander introduced a new platform that improved ride quality and handling. The hybrid powertrain was also significantly enhanced, offering even better fuel economy. These models offer a modern driving experience with a focus on efficiency. The interior design is also more upscale compared to previous generations.
2023-Present: Turbocharged Engine and Technology Updates
The 2023 Highlander replaced the V6 engine with a turbocharged four-cylinder engine, offering a blend of performance and fuel efficiency. It also received technology updates, including a new infotainment system. The turbocharged engine provides ample power while maintaining competitive fuel economy. These newer models offer the latest features and technology.
Reliability: A Highlander Hallmark
One of the main reasons the Toyota Highlander is so highly regarded is its exceptional reliability. Across all generations, the Highlander has consistently earned high marks for reliability from various consumer reports and automotive publications. While specific issues may arise in certain model years, the Highlander, as a whole, boasts a track record of durability and longevity. Regular maintenance is key to ensuring its continued performance.
Comparing the Generations: Strengths and Weaknesses
Each generation of the Toyota Highlander has its own set of strengths and weaknesses. The first generation offers affordability and simplicity, while the second generation provides increased space and refinement. The third generation boasts modern features and hybrid options, and the fourth generation delivers a contemporary design and advanced technology.
First Generation (2001-2007):
- Strengths: Affordability, simplicity, proven reliability.
- Weaknesses: Lacks modern features, less spacious than later generations.
Second Generation (2008-2013):
- Strengths: Increased space, improved comfort, good value.
- Weaknesses: Styling may be dated, fuel economy not as good as later models.
Third Generation (2014-2019):
- Strengths: Modern features, advanced safety technology, available hybrid powertrain.
- Weaknesses: Can be more expensive than earlier generations.
Fourth Generation (2020-Present):
- Strengths: Contemporary design, advanced technology, excellent fuel economy (especially hybrid), refined driving experience.
- Weaknesses: Higher price point, turbocharged engine (2023+) may not appeal to everyone.
Which Highlander is the Best? Tailoring the Choice to Your Needs
The “best” Toyota Highlander ultimately depends on your individual needs and budget.
- For Budget-Conscious Buyers: The first or second generation Highlanders offer excellent value for the money. Look for well-maintained models with a comprehensive service history.
- For Families Prioritizing Space and Comfort: The second or third generation Highlanders provide ample interior space and a comfortable ride.
- For Tech-Savvy Drivers: The third or fourth generation Highlanders offer advanced technology features and modern amenities.
- For Eco-Conscious Buyers: The hybrid versions of the third and fourth generation Highlanders provide excellent fuel economy and reduced emissions.
Factors to Consider Before Buying
Before making a purchase, consider the following factors:
- Budget: Determine how much you are willing to spend. Prices vary significantly depending on the model year, trim level, and condition.
- Needs: Assess your space requirements, desired features, and fuel economy preferences.
- Reliability: Research the specific model year for any potential issues or recalls.
- Maintenance History: Obtain a vehicle history report and review the maintenance records to ensure the Highlander has been properly maintained.
- Test Drive: Take the Highlander for a test drive to evaluate its performance, handling, and comfort.
Final Verdict: The Sweet Spot Highlanders
While personal preferences play a crucial role, some Toyota Highlander model years stand out as particularly desirable. For a balance of features, reliability, and value, the 2011-2013 (second generation) and 2017-2019 (third generation) models are often considered the sweet spot. These Highlanders offer a good blend of modern amenities, proven reliability, and reasonable pricing. However, the newer fourth-generation models (2020-Present) are excellent choices if you prioritize the latest technology and fuel efficiency, especially the hybrid variants, provided they fit your budget. Ultimately, the best Highlander is the one that best meets your specific needs and preferences.
What are the key differences between the Toyota Highlander generations?
Each Toyota Highlander generation brings significant changes, reflecting advancements in technology, design, and performance. The first generation (2001-2007) pioneered the crossover SUV segment with its car-like handling and comfortable ride. The second generation (2008-2013) increased in size, offering more passenger and cargo space, and introduced more sophisticated features. The third generation (2014-2019) emphasized styling and fuel efficiency, while the fourth generation (2020-present) boasts a more refined interior, updated technology, and a hybrid powertrain option across various trim levels.
Across generations, the Highlander has evolved in terms of engine options, safety features, and interior design. Earlier models focused on reliability and practicality, while newer models incorporate advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS), premium materials, and larger infotainment screens. Understanding these generational shifts is crucial when deciding which used Highlander best suits your needs and budget.
Which Highlander generation offers the best fuel economy?
The fourth generation (2020-present) Toyota Highlander, particularly the hybrid models, offers the best fuel economy. The Highlander Hybrid boasts impressive MPG figures, making it a cost-effective choice for those prioritizing fuel efficiency.
The hybrid system combines a gasoline engine with electric motors, resulting in significantly improved fuel economy compared to previous generations’ gasoline-only options. If fuel efficiency is your top priority, focusing on the fourth generation hybrid variants is the most logical choice.
Which Highlander generation is considered the most reliable?
While all Toyota Highlanders are known for their reliability, the second generation (2008-2013) is often cited as exceptionally dependable. This generation has a proven track record with fewer reported issues compared to some other years.
Its well-established engine options and relatively simple technology contribute to its reliability. Many owners report high mileage with minimal repairs, making it a popular choice for those seeking a long-lasting and dependable SUV.
What are the common problems to look out for when buying a used Highlander?
When purchasing a used Toyota Highlander, it’s essential to inspect for potential issues specific to each generation. Common problems across various years may include oil leaks, especially in older models, and potential issues with the infotainment system.
For earlier generations, inspect the condition of the suspension components and check for any signs of rust. Fourth-generation models, while generally reliable, should be carefully assessed for any hybrid system issues if you’re considering a hybrid variant. A thorough pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic is always recommended.
Which Highlander generation offers the most cargo space?
The second and third generations (2008-2019) of the Toyota Highlander generally offer the most cargo space. These generations provide ample room for passengers and their belongings, making them ideal for families or those needing to haul larger items.
While the fourth generation is spacious, the slightly larger dimensions of the second and third generations give them a slight edge in terms of overall cargo volume, particularly with the third-row seats folded down. If cargo capacity is a primary concern, these generations should be considered.
Which Highlander generation offers the most advanced safety features?
The fourth generation (2020-present) Toyota Highlander comes equipped with the most advanced safety features. This generation incorporates the latest iteration of Toyota Safety Sense, including features like pre-collision system with pedestrian detection, lane departure alert with steering assist, and adaptive cruise control.
These advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) provide an enhanced level of safety and driver confidence. While earlier generations offer safety features, the technology in the fourth generation is significantly more sophisticated and comprehensive.
Which Highlander generation is the best value for money?
Determining the “best value” depends on individual priorities and budget. The second generation (2008-2013) often represents a good balance between affordability and reliability, offering a proven track record and a reasonable price point on the used market.
However, the third generation (2014-2019) provides a more modern design and additional features at a slightly higher price, potentially representing better value for those seeking a more contemporary vehicle. Ultimately, the best value depends on your specific needs and how much you’re willing to spend.