The Toyota Yaris has been a popular compact car for decades, praised for its reliability, fuel efficiency, and affordability. As a subcompact vehicle, it’s marketed toward urban drivers and budget-conscious buyers, but not every model year is equal. Some models excel due to improvements in safety and tech, while others suffered from recalls or performance issues. If you’re in the market to buy a pre-owned Toyota Yaris—or looking to upgrade your current ride—you may be wondering, “Which year Toyota Yaris is best?”
This article dives deep into every model year of the Toyota Yaris, evaluating them based on reliability, performance, technological innovation, safety ratings, and owner feedback to help you make a well-informed decision.
Overview of the Toyota Yaris Generations
Before we compare specific model years, let’s understand the major design changes across the Toyota Yaris’s generation lifecycle:
1st Generation (1999–2005)
- Introduced in 1999 in global markets.
- In the U.S., the Yaris made its debut in 2007 with this platform but under a redesigned nameplate.
- Limited features and fuel-efficient small engines.
2nd Generation (2005–2013)
- First model year for the U.S. in 2007 as a replacement for the Echo.
- Notable changes: improved engine output, roomier interior.
- Redesigned in 2012 for better looks and improved tech.
3rd Generation (2013–2020)
- Marked a sleeker design and more spacious cabin.
- Stronger focus on safety with standard features like anti-lock brakes and stability control.
- Some key model years: 2016–2018 receive praise for tech upgrades and crash-test scores.
4th Generation (2020–Present)
- Launched globally in 2018; North America first received it in 2020.
- Larger than previous models, better engine performance (106 HP base engine), and more advanced safety systems.
- Offers AWD in certain models.
Now that we’ve established a base of understanding, let’s get into the best years for the Toyota Yaris in the U.S. market—where the story really begins in 2007.
Best Toyota Yaris Model Years
Best Overall: 2019 Toyota Yaris
The 2019 Yaris was the last of the third-generation models before the shift in 2020. It offered:
- Improved fuel economy (30/37 mpg city/highway).
- Enhanced infotainment with Apple CarPlay compatibility starting mid-year.
- Five-star NHTSA safety rating and strong IIHS scores.
Owners praised its reliability and smooth ride, and reliability portals such as Consumer Reports rated it highly for trouble-free ownership. The 1.5L four-cylinder engine provided sufficient performance for city driving without causing concern over maintenance issues seen in other higher-tech years.
Runner-up: 2021 Toyota Yaris
The 2021 model year signaled the strong entry of the fourth-generation Yaris into the American market. Toyota took lessons from the past and delivered a better car in terms of:
- Engine options including optional AWD.
- New sedan body style offering both style and practicality.
- Improved handling.
- Higher interior quality compared to previous generations.
Safety systems like Toyota Safety Sense (TSS) came standard, which included features like forward collision warning, lane departure alert, adaptive cruise control, and automatic high beams. The 2021 also saw a significant weight reduction thanks to its TNGA platform, improving both fuel efficiency and durability.
Additionally, the 2021 model year had fewer reported complaints, making it an attractive choice for buyers looking for a near-new used car.
Also Excellent: 2018 Toyota Yaris
The 2018 Yaris represented the best of the third-generation model with:
- A redesigned suspension tuned for comfort and urban agility.
- More modern tech interfaces.
- Strong crash test results from both IIHS and NHTSA.
However, it didn’t feature the Apple CarPlay support that became available in 2019, but for drivers not dependent on smartphone integration, it remains a solid choice.
Durable and Dependable: 2007 Toyota Yaris
The very first U.S. generation of the Yaris was relatively basic but gained praise for its exceptional reliability and mechanical simplicity. Known for long service life without major repairs, many 2007 models still see roads today. However, the vehicle lacked modern safety and tech—so while reliable, it’s outdated in key areas.
Toyota Yaris Year-by-Year Breakdown
A complete ranking by year to help you evaluate each option:
2007 Toyota Yaris
- Pros: Mechanical reliability, low depreciation, fuel-efficient 1.5L engine.
- Cons: No modern safety features, very basic interior, no tech beyond AM/FM.
2008 Toyota Yaris
- Minor mechanical upgrades.
- Continued reliability trends.
- Slight improvements in upholstery and ergonomics.
- Notable for being among the first Toyota cars to offer side curtain airbags.
2009 Toyota Yaris
- Introduced optional automatic transmission with better fuel mapping.
- Strong resale value.
- A common first car—and a smart entry-level buy for those prioritizing cost.
2010 Toyota Yaris
- Standard stability control added—enhancing crash avoidance.
- Minor facelift and slightly more luxurious interior trims such as LE.
- One of the best years in the first generation.
2011 Toyota Yaris
- Some complaints of powertrain issues, particularly with transmission fluid leaks.
- Slower sales due to minimal updates.
- Avoid if purchasing a high-mileage example.
2012 Toyota Yaris
- Redesigned body with much better aesthetics.
- Better aerodynamics.
- Tech improvements: optional navigation and backup camera.
2013 Toyota Yaris
- New third-generation platform introduced.
- Vastly upgraded structure: roomier cabin, longer list of standard features.
- Marking a turning point in quality and appeal.
2014 Toyota Yaris
- Minor refinements to interior and drivetrain.
- Transmission improvements to eliminate previous lag.
- Solid ownership experience with minimal complaints.
2015 Toyota Yaris
- Enhanced infotainment—Bluetooth and USB standard.
- Transmission options continue to mature.
- Considered a good value for budget-conscious buyers with modern comforts.
2016 Toyota Yaris
- Better engine and transmission calibration.
- Improved steering and fuel economy.
- Strong for a pre-2018 model year.
2017 Toyota Yaris
- Minor updates, mainly to tech.
- Mid-cycle refinement that maintained smooth performance.
- Slight weight reduction and aerodynamic changes.
2018 Toyota Yaris
- Updated chassis, better safety scores.
- More premium options available like LED headlights.
- Still reliable, but more complex than earlier models.
2019 Toyota Yaris
- Best combination of updated tech, reliability, and safety.
- Apple CarPlay added mid-year across all trims.
- NHTSA and IIHS five-star ratings.
- Ideal for budget buyers seeking modern features.
2020 Toyota Yaris
- Introduction of the fourth-generation.
- Based on the TNGA platform.
- More powerful 1.5L engine and 8-speed automatic transmission.
- Standard Toyota Safety Sense on all trims.
2021 Toyota Yaris
- Minor trim updates.
- Slightly revised styling cues.
- Very reliable with few reported issues.
2022 Toyota Yaris
- Continued enhancements to cabin materials and ride comfort.
- Still relatively new, but data suggests continued reliability.
2023 Toyota Yaris
- No major changes from 2022.
- Additional dealer incentives made it a compelling low-cost purchase in 2023.
2024 Toyota Yaris
- The latest Yaris, still early in its depreciation curve.
- Toyota continues to modernize the platform with hybrid possibility.
Toyota Yaris: Best Years Compared
To help you narrow your choices further, here’s a comparison table of the best Toyota Yaris model years with their key features:
| Year | Horsepower | Safety Package | Fuel Economy (Average) | Infotainment Highlights | Overall Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | 106 | No TSS, no advanced safety features | 30/37 mpg | AM/FM only | 8/10 |
| 2013 | 106 | Basic stability control | 30/37 mpg | Touchscreen, USB, Bluetooth | 8.2/10 |
| 2018 | 106 | Optional Safety Sense | 30/37 mpg | 6.1” touchscreen, Bluetooth | 8.5/10 |
| 2019 | 106 | Mid-year TSS add-on | 30/37 mpg | CarPlay, Android Auto | 9.1/10 |
| 2020 | 106 | Standard TSS | 32/40 mpg (TNGA) | 7” touchscreen, Smart Connect | 8.9/10 |
| 2021 | 106 | Standard TSS 2.0 | 32.5/40 mpg | CarPlay, Alexa, Amazon Music | 9.3/10 |
Worst Toyota Yaris Years to Avoid
2010 Model Year
While the 2010 Yaris had improvements in safety and design, many units suffer from electronic throttle control issues, infotainment glitches, and occasional engine stalling. These problems were not unique to the Yaris, as they coincided with a larger Toyota recall involving unintended acceleration. While repairs were done and most units were fixed, buying a 2010 model without verified service history is a risk.
2011 Toyota Yaris
The 2011 model received numerous complaints, particularly for premature timing chain wear (common in other small Toyota engines), transmission fluid leaks, and interior climate controls issues. While not every unit experienced these symptoms, the high volume of reports should steer buyers away from this year unless in pristine condition and priced low.
Common Problems Across Toyota Yaris Years
While generally reliable, different generations and trims have experienced varying mechanical and electronic failures over the years:
Infotainment and Connectivity Issues
- Observed in: 2013–2017 models.
- Problems: Touchscreen freezing, Bluetooth malfunctions, navigation system failure.
- Tip: If buying one of these years, test connectivity thoroughly.
Transmission & Shifting Problems
- Sporadic instances in 2008–2010 and early 2013 models.
- Issue: Slipping gears, harsh shifts, early transmission failure (especially in used high-mileage vehicles).
Engine Concerns
- The 1.5L engine is known to be efficient but low on power.
- Some 2011–2014 models faced unusual timing chain wear.
- Newer generations (2018+) show fewer reports of these issues.
How to Choose the Best Toyota Yaris for Your Needs
Ultimately, purchasing a Toyota Yaris isn’t just about the model year—it’s also about matching the vehicle to your lifestyle and needs. Here are a few questions to ask yourself:
Are You Buying New or Used?
- If new or nearly new (within 3 years), 2020 to 2023 offer the latest tech and safety.
- Pre-owned or budget purchases should consider 2018–2019—the high point in features and reliability.
What Is Your Primary Use?
- City driving and efficiency? Most Yaris years fit this well.
- Family or daily commuter? Look at models from 2017 onward with ample safety features.
How Important Is Tech?
- Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and Alexa come standard from 2019+.
- Early models lack smartphone integration or suffer from outdated interfaces.
Are You a DIY Maintenance Person?
- Older models (2007–2012) are more mechanically simple and easier to repair at home.
- Newer models rely heavily on diagnostics and advanced systems.
Final Thoughts: Which Year Yaris Is the Best?
In conclusion, the 2019 and 2021 Toyota Yaris models stand out as the best options. The 2019 Yaris offers a sweet spot between cost, modern infotainment features, and reliability. The 2021 model benefits from Toyota’s newer safety standards and the solid underpinnings of the TNGA platform.
Your mileage preference, budget, location, and intended use also play into which year you’ll choose. However, if the goal is to own a Yaris with a high comfort-safety-tech-reliability ratio, focus your search on 2018 and newer or look for 2020–2023 if you’re aiming for near-new quality without sticker shock.
Bottom Line:
- Best overall year: 2019 Toyota Yaris
- Best modern model: 2021 Toyota Yaris
- Best value pre-2018: 2013 Toyota Yaris
- Worst years to avoid: 2010, 2011 Yaris
Whether you’re a college student, budget-conscious family, or everyday commuter, selecting the best Toyota Yaris for you means weighing the needs of today with the long-term durability of the car. The Yaris, in its better years, checks almost every box without the premium price.
What is the best model year for the Toyota Yaris?
The 2020 Toyota Yaris is often cited as one of the best model years due to its modern safety features, reliable performance, and a refined interior. This model was the first to adopt Toyota’s TNGA platform, which significantly improved ride quality, handling, and crash safety. It also introduced a host of standard tech features like Apple CarPlay and Android Auto compatibility, making it more appealing to younger and tech-oriented buyers.
Additionally, the 2020 Yaris retained the vehicle’s core strengths—fuel efficiency and low maintenance costs—while addressing previous shortcomings in ride dynamics and safety features. Toyota’s reputation for reliability also holds strong for this year, with few recalls or widespread mechanical issues reported. For buyers seeking a balance between comfort, safety, and affordability, the 2020 Yaris is a standout option.
Which Toyota Yaris models should I avoid?
Certain older model years of the Toyota Yaris are best avoided due to reliability issues and dated features. The 2007 and 2008 models, for example, are commonly reported to suffer from transmission problems, especially in the automatic versions. Similarly, the 2013 model year saw several complaints about engine failure and erratic performance, particularly among vehicles equipped with the continuously variable transmission (CVT).
Another year to be cautious about is 2017, which, while generally reliable, had a number of complaints about HVAC issues and premature wear on interior materials. These concerns don’t mean these models should automatically be ruled out, but they do suggest that potential buyers should perform thorough inspections and review maintenance history carefully when considering these years.
How does the 2019 Toyota Yaris compare to other years?
The 2019 Toyota Yaris offers a solid mix of reliability, affordability, and comfort, making it one of the more balanced models before the TNGA redesign. It offered better fuel economy than many of its competitors, a comfortable ride, and access to various tech and safety options, though most were not standard like in later models. It’s known for its dependable 1.5L inline-4 engine and generally smooth driving experience.
However, when compared to the 2020 and newer models, the 2019 lacks the structural benefits of the TNGA platform and misses out on the more refined interior and enhanced tech features introduced the following year. That said, for buyers on a tight budget or preferring a non-CVT automatic transmission, the 2019 model can be a strong contender, especially if well-maintained.
Are newer Toyota Yaris models better than older ones?
In general, newer Toyota Yaris models are considered superior due to updated technology, better safety features, and improved driving dynamics. Starting with the 2020 redesign, Toyota significantly upgraded the Yaris with a new TNGA-based chassis, enhancing both ride quality and crash safety. These models also include a host of standard driver-assist technologies under Toyota Safety Sense, giving newer owners more confidence on the road.
However, some buyers prefer older models for their mechanical simplicity and proven reliability over time. The older, pre-TNGA models often used reliable automatic transmissions instead of CVTs, which can be a concern for some consumers. If you’re focused on the latest safety and tech features, newer is better, but for a classic, no-frills reliability experience, older models may still appeal.
What should I look for when buying a used Toyota Yaris?
When purchasing a used Toyota Yaris, it’s important to consider the model year and associated reliability trends. Check for any known issues with that specific year, and request a vehicle history report to reveal past accidents or service records. Pay particular attention to transmission type—newer models use a CVT, which has had mixed reviews, but offers generally improved fuel economy over the traditional automatic.
Also, inspect the condition of the interior, HVAC system, and electronics, as some older models had issues with premature interior wear and HVAC failures. Take the car for a test drive and observe for unusual noises, hesitation, or fluid leaks. A pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic can also help ensure that you’re getting a reliable example of this popular subcompact.
Is the Toyota Yaris a reliable car overall?
Yes, the Toyota Yaris has a well-earned reputation for reliability, especially in its mid-2010s models. Toyota’s engineering and high build quality standards contribute to consistent performance and long-term durability across many model years. Routine maintenance is generally affordable, and parts are widely available, which helps keep repair costs low even as the car ages.
That said, reliability can vary depending on the specific model year, owner maintenance habits, and driving conditions. While some years had issues like early transmission failure, these problems were not widespread enough to tarnish the Yaris’ overall reputation. With proper care, most Yaris models will surpass 200,000 miles without major issues, making it a strong choice in the used subcompact market.
How much should I expect to pay for a used Toyota Yaris?
The price of a used Toyota Yaris varies widely depending on year, trim level, mileage, and location. Older models, like those from 2007–2010, can often be found for under $5,000, especially in high-mileage configurations. These cars are good options for budget buyers who can handle potential mechanical age-related repairs.
A moderately used 2015 to 2018 Yaris with around 50,000 to 80,000 miles generally falls in the $8,000–$12,000 range. The newer 2020 and 2021 models, which come with enhanced safety features and upgraded interiors, usually cost between $13,000–$18,000 depending on condition and trim level. Always consider the long-term value and cost of ownership when setting a price range, as the Yaris has strong resale value and low operating costs.