The Toyota Highlander has consistently ranked as a top choice in the mid-size SUV segment. Known for its reliability, spaciousness, and family-friendly features, it’s a vehicle that often tops “best of” lists. But with so many model years available, pinpointing the absolute “best” can be tricky. It depends entirely on your individual needs, budget, and priorities. This comprehensive guide dives deep into the Highlander’s history, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each generation to help you make an informed decision.
Understanding the Highlander Generations
To determine the best year, it’s crucial to understand the different generations of the Highlander. Each generation brought significant updates in terms of styling, technology, engine options, and safety features.
First Generation (2001-2007)
The first generation Highlander marked Toyota’s entry into the crossover SUV market. Based on the Camry platform, it offered car-like handling and a comfortable ride.
Key Features of the First Generation
These models typically came with either a 2.4-liter four-cylinder engine or a 3.0-liter V6. The V6 provided significantly more power and was generally the preferred choice. Interior space was adequate for its time, with an optional third-row seat. Safety features were standard for the era, including anti-lock brakes and front airbags.
Potential Issues and Considerations
Older models are more prone to wear and tear. Potential issues include rust, particularly in regions with harsh winters, and common maintenance items associated with older vehicles. Fuel economy is also less impressive compared to newer models.
Second Generation (2008-2013)
The second generation Highlander saw a significant increase in size and refinement. It became a true mid-size SUV, offering more space for passengers and cargo.
Improvements and New Features
Engine options expanded to include a 2.7-liter four-cylinder and a 3.5-liter V6. The V6 was the more popular choice due to its improved performance. This generation also introduced a hybrid model, combining fuel efficiency with SUV practicality. The interior was noticeably upgraded, with better materials and more features.
Specific Model Year Highlights
The 2011 model year received a mid-cycle refresh, with updated styling and additional features. This refresh made it a particularly desirable choice within the second generation.
Third Generation (2014-2019)
The third generation Highlander brought a more stylish and modern design, along with updated technology and enhanced safety features.
Styling, Technology, and Safety Upgrades
This generation featured a bolder exterior design and a more refined interior. Technology upgrades included a touchscreen infotainment system and available driver-assistance features like lane departure warning and adaptive cruise control. Safety was a major focus, with improved crash test ratings and a suite of advanced safety technologies.
Reliability and Common Issues
The third generation Highlander is generally considered very reliable. However, some owners have reported issues with the infotainment system and the automatic transmission. Regular maintenance is key to preventing major problems.
Fourth Generation (2020-Present)
The fourth generation Highlander boasts a completely redesigned exterior, a more luxurious interior, and improved fuel efficiency.
Engine Options and Fuel Efficiency
This generation offers a standard 3.5-liter V6 engine and a hybrid powertrain. The hybrid model provides excellent fuel economy, making it a great choice for environmentally conscious buyers.
Interior Design and Technology
The interior is significantly more upscale than previous generations, with high-quality materials and a modern design. The technology is also top-notch, with a large touchscreen display and advanced driver-assistance features.
Choosing the Best Year for You: Factors to Consider
Determining the best year for you involves carefully considering your individual needs and priorities. Here are some key factors to keep in mind:
Budget
Your budget will play a significant role in determining which model year is within your reach. Newer models will naturally command a higher price.
Desired Features
Consider which features are most important to you. Do you need advanced safety features, a specific infotainment system, or a hybrid powertrain?
Fuel Efficiency
If fuel efficiency is a top priority, the hybrid models are the best choice. Newer generations generally offer better fuel economy than older ones.
Reliability
The Highlander has a reputation for reliability across all generations. However, newer models will generally have fewer miles and less wear and tear.
Maintenance Costs
Factor in potential maintenance costs when making your decision. Older models may require more frequent repairs and maintenance.
Specific Model Year Recommendations
While the “best” year is subjective, here are some specific model years that stand out for various reasons:
Best Value: 2015-2016
These model years offer a great balance of features, reliability, and affordability. They fall within the sweet spot of the third generation, offering modern styling and technology without the higher price tag of the newest models.
Top Safety Pick: 2017-2019
These years consistently earned high safety ratings from both the IIHS and NHTSA. They also come equipped with a comprehensive suite of advanced safety features.
Best Fuel Economy: 2020-Present Hybrid
If fuel economy is your top priority, the fourth-generation hybrid models are the clear winner. They offer impressive fuel efficiency without sacrificing performance or practicality.
Most Luxurious: 2023-Present
The latest model years offer the most luxurious interior and the most advanced technology features. They also come with the latest safety innovations.
Comparing Popular Model Years
Let’s take a closer look at some popular model years and compare their key features:
2012 Toyota Highlander vs. 2017 Toyota Highlander
The 2012 model represents the tail end of the second generation, while the 2017 is mid-cycle for the third. The 2017 boasts updated styling, enhanced safety features (like Toyota Safety Sense), and a more refined interior. The 2012 is still a reliable choice, but the 2017 offers a more modern experience.
2016 Toyota Highlander vs. 2020 Toyota Highlander
The 2016 represents the sweet spot in the third generation, offering a good blend of features and affordability. The 2020 marks the beginning of the fourth generation, with a completely redesigned exterior and interior, improved fuel efficiency, and the latest technology. The 2020 is a significant upgrade in terms of design and features, but the 2016 is a more budget-friendly option.
Checking Vehicle History and Getting an Inspection
Regardless of which model year you choose, it’s crucial to thoroughly inspect the vehicle and check its history.
Importance of Vehicle History Reports
A vehicle history report, such as Carfax or AutoCheck, can reveal important information about the vehicle’s past, including accidents, title issues, and maintenance records.
Pre-Purchase Inspection by a Mechanic
Before making a purchase, it’s highly recommended to have the vehicle inspected by a qualified mechanic. They can identify any potential problems that may not be apparent during a visual inspection.
Final Thoughts: Finding Your Perfect Highlander
The Toyota Highlander is a consistently excellent choice for families and individuals seeking a reliable, spacious, and versatile SUV. The “best” year ultimately depends on your individual needs, budget, and preferences. By carefully considering the factors outlined in this guide and conducting thorough research, you can confidently choose the Highlander that’s perfect for you. Remember to prioritize safety, reliability, and features that align with your lifestyle. Happy car hunting!
What are some of the key factors to consider when choosing the best year for a used Toyota Highlander?
Choosing the best year for a used Toyota Highlander involves considering several factors to ensure you get a reliable and suitable vehicle. Important aspects include budget, desired features, fuel efficiency, safety ratings, and potential maintenance needs. Researching common problems or recalls for specific years is also crucial to avoid costly repairs down the line. Examining consumer reviews and reliability scores from reputable sources can provide valuable insights into the long-term performance of different Highlander model years.
Furthermore, consider your specific needs and driving habits. If you require advanced technology features like Apple CarPlay or Android Auto, newer models might be preferable. If you prioritize cargo space or passenger comfort, research the interior dimensions and seating configurations of various years. Finally, don’t neglect the importance of a pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic to assess the vehicle’s overall condition and identify any potential issues before making a final decision.
Which Toyota Highlander generation is generally considered the most reliable?
The second generation Toyota Highlander (2008-2013) is often lauded for its exceptional reliability and balanced features. It strikes a good balance between offering modern amenities and avoiding some of the more complex technologies that can sometimes lead to problems in newer vehicles. Many owners report minimal issues and long-term durability with proper maintenance, making it a popular choice for those seeking a dependable used SUV.
While newer generations offer more advanced features and updated styling, the second-generation Highlander has proven its resilience and earned a reputation for longevity. Its engine options, particularly the V6, are known for their robustness, and the interior is comfortable and functional. Finding a well-maintained second-generation Highlander can offer excellent value and peace of mind for buyers prioritizing reliability.
Are there any specific Toyota Highlander model years to avoid due to known problems?
While the Toyota Highlander generally boasts excellent reliability, some model years have exhibited more issues than others. Certain years within the third generation (2014-2019) have been reported to have potential transmission problems or issues with the infotainment system. Thorough research into specific model years within this generation is advisable to determine if these issues are prevalent and to understand the potential costs of addressing them.
It is important to note that not all vehicles from these years will experience these problems, and proper maintenance can mitigate the risk. However, being aware of potential issues allows buyers to make informed decisions and factor potential repair costs into their budget. Consulting online forums, consumer reports, and conducting thorough inspections can help identify any red flags before purchasing.
What are the differences between the various Toyota Highlander trim levels and how do they impact the ideal model year?
Toyota Highlander trim levels typically range from the base L to the higher-end Limited and Platinum trims, each offering a different level of features and luxury. Lower trim levels usually prioritize practicality and affordability, offering essential features like air conditioning, power windows, and basic infotainment systems. Higher trims add features like leather upholstery, sunroofs, advanced safety systems, premium audio systems, and enhanced styling elements.
The ideal model year is influenced by the trim level you desire. If you’re seeking advanced technology like adaptive cruise control or a panoramic sunroof, you’ll likely need to consider newer models with higher trim levels, such as Limited or Platinum. If your priority is affordability and basic functionality, an older model with a lower trim level like the LE or LE Plus might suffice. Understanding the specific features offered by each trim level in different model years is essential for finding the best fit for your needs and budget.
How does the engine choice (4-cylinder vs. V6) affect the best year for a used Toyota Highlander?
The engine choice in a used Toyota Highlander significantly impacts its performance, fuel economy, and overall suitability for your needs. While the 4-cylinder engine offers better fuel efficiency, it may lack the power needed for towing or carrying heavy loads, particularly in earlier model years. The V6 engine provides more robust performance and towing capacity, making it a better choice for those who require extra power or frequently transport passengers or cargo.
The availability of each engine option varies across different model years. Early models might offer both engine choices, while newer generations may prioritize the V6 or even hybrid powertrains. Consider your typical driving scenarios and power requirements when selecting a model year. If you primarily drive in the city and prioritize fuel economy, a 4-cylinder model from a year when it was well-regarded might suffice. If you need ample power for highway driving or towing, a V6 model from a reliable year is likely the better option.
How do hybrid versions of the Toyota Highlander factor into choosing the best model year?
Hybrid versions of the Toyota Highlander offer significantly improved fuel economy compared to their gasoline-only counterparts, making them an attractive option for environmentally conscious buyers or those seeking to reduce fuel costs. However, hybrid technology adds complexity, and the reliability of the hybrid system can vary across different model years. It’s crucial to research the specific hybrid system used in the Highlander you’re considering and look for any reported issues with the battery, electric motor, or regenerative braking system.
When considering a hybrid Highlander, pay close attention to the battery’s age and condition. Hybrid batteries typically have a lifespan of 8-10 years, and replacement can be costly. Check the vehicle’s maintenance records for any battery-related services or replacements. Newer hybrid models often come with longer battery warranties, which can provide added peace of mind. Evaluating the hybrid system’s reliability and battery health is essential for determining the best year for a used hybrid Toyota Highlander.
What steps should I take to ensure I am getting a good deal on a used Toyota Highlander, regardless of the model year?
Regardless of the specific model year, thorough research and careful evaluation are crucial for securing a good deal on a used Toyota Highlander. Start by comparing prices from multiple sources, including online marketplaces, dealerships, and private sellers. Use online valuation tools to get an estimated market value for the specific Highlander you’re interested in, considering its mileage, condition, and features.
Next, schedule a pre-purchase inspection with a qualified mechanic to assess the vehicle’s overall condition and identify any potential issues. Negotiate the price based on the inspection results and any necessary repairs. Always obtain a vehicle history report to check for accidents, title issues, or odometer discrepancies. Finally, secure financing from multiple lenders to compare interest rates and loan terms to get the best possible deal.