The Toyota Highlander has consistently ranked as a top choice for families seeking a reliable, spacious, and safe SUV. Known for its longevity and strong resale value, the Highlander makes an excellent used car purchase. However, with several generations and numerous model years to choose from, pinpointing the best year can be a challenge. This guide delves deep into the Highlander’s history, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each generation to help you make an informed decision.
Understanding the Highlander’s Generations
Before diving into specific years, it’s crucial to understand the Highlander’s generational shifts. Each generation brought significant changes in design, technology, and performance. Knowing these differences will help you narrow down your search based on your specific needs and budget.
First Generation (2001-2007): The Original Crossover
The first-generation Highlander essentially created the crossover SUV segment. Based on the Camry platform, it offered a car-like ride with the practicality of an SUV. It was available with either a four-cylinder or a V6 engine. The early models, particularly those from 2001-2003, can be found at very attractive prices, but may show their age in terms of technology and safety features. The 2004-2007 models received a mid-cycle refresh, improving styling and adding some modern features.
Pros of the First Generation
These Highlanders are affordable, reliable, and easy to maintain. Parts are readily available and relatively inexpensive. The V6 engine provides adequate power for most driving situations. The interior, while basic, is durable and functional.
Cons of the First Generation
Safety features are less advanced compared to newer models. Fuel economy is not impressive, especially with the V6. The ride quality is acceptable but not as refined as later generations. The four-cylinder engine can feel underpowered when fully loaded.
Second Generation (2008-2013): Bigger and Bolder
The second-generation Highlander grew in size, offering more interior space and a more aggressive design. It continued to be available with a V6 engine, and a hybrid variant was introduced. This generation offered significant improvements in ride quality, handling, and interior refinement.
Pros of the Second Generation
The second generation boasts a more spacious and comfortable interior than its predecessor. The V6 engine offers ample power and improved fuel economy. The hybrid model provides excellent fuel efficiency. The ride is smoother and more refined. Available features like a backup camera and navigation system add convenience.
Cons of the Second Generation
Early models (2008-2010) had some reported issues with oil consumption in the V6 engine. The third-row seat is still best suited for children. The exterior styling can be polarizing.
Third Generation (2014-2019): Modern and Refined
The third-generation Highlander brought a modern design, a more comfortable interior, and updated technology. It continued to be available with a V6 engine and a hybrid option. This generation prioritized family comfort and convenience, making it a popular choice for those seeking a practical and reliable SUV.
Pros of the Third Generation
The third generation offers a stylish exterior and a well-appointed interior. The V6 engine delivers strong performance and decent fuel economy. Safety features are significantly improved, including available features like lane departure warning and adaptive cruise control. The ride is quiet and comfortable. The third-row seat is more usable than in previous generations.
Cons of the Third Generation
Some reviewers found the handling to be less engaging than some competitors. The infotainment system can feel dated in earlier models. The base four-cylinder engine is underpowered for some drivers.
Fourth Generation (2020-Present): Tech-Focused and Fuel-Efficient
The fourth-generation Highlander features a completely redesigned exterior and interior, along with updated technology and safety features. It continues to be available with a V6 engine and a hybrid powertrain, now offering even better fuel economy. This generation emphasizes fuel efficiency, technology integration, and driver assistance features.
Pros of the Fourth Generation
The fourth generation offers a stylish and modern design. The interior is well-designed and features high-quality materials. Fuel economy is excellent, especially with the hybrid powertrain. Advanced safety features are standard, including Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+. The infotainment system is user-friendly and offers smartphone integration.
Cons of the Fourth Generation
The V6 engine was dropped in the 2023 model year in favor of a turbocharged four-cylinder. The third-row seat is still relatively small compared to some competitors. Higher trims can be expensive.
Choosing the Best Year: Key Considerations
Several factors come into play when determining the “best” year of used Highlander to buy. Your budget is perhaps the most significant, but your needs and priorities also matter. Do you prioritize fuel economy, safety features, interior space, or technology?
Budget
Your budget will significantly limit your options. First-generation Highlanders are the most affordable, while fourth-generation models are the most expensive. Keep in mind that lower prices may come with higher mileage and potential maintenance needs.
Safety
If safety is a top priority, consider models from 2014 onward. These Highlanders offer advanced safety features like lane departure warning, adaptive cruise control, and blind-spot monitoring. Look for models with a good crash test rating from the IIHS and NHTSA.
Fuel Economy
The hybrid Highlander models offer the best fuel economy. The second-generation hybrid (2008-2013) provides a good balance of fuel efficiency and affordability. The fourth-generation hybrid offers even better fuel economy but comes at a higher price.
Technology
If you want modern technology features like a touchscreen infotainment system, smartphone integration, and advanced driver assistance features, focus on models from 2014 onward. However, be aware that the technology in older models may feel dated compared to newer vehicles.
Reliability
The Toyota Highlander has a reputation for reliability, but some years have had more reported issues than others. Research common problems for each model year to make an informed decision. Consult resources like Consumer Reports and J.D. Power for reliability ratings.
Specific Year Recommendations
Considering all the factors mentioned above, here are some specific year recommendations based on different priorities:
Best Value (Budget-Friendly): 2007 Toyota Highlander
The 2007 Highlander is the final year of the first generation and represents a sweet spot for affordability and reliability. It offers a proven V6 engine, decent features for its age, and can be found at very attractive prices. While it lacks the modern amenities of newer models, it’s a solid choice for those on a tight budget. Just be sure to have a mechanic inspect it thoroughly before purchasing.
Best Balance of Features and Price: 2015 Toyota Highlander
The 2015 Highlander falls within the third generation, offering a significant upgrade in terms of design, technology, and safety compared to earlier models. It features a comfortable interior, a smooth ride, and available advanced safety features like lane departure warning and adaptive cruise control. It also offers a good balance between price and features, making it an excellent value for the money.
Best Fuel Economy: 2018 Toyota Highlander Hybrid
For those prioritizing fuel economy without sacrificing too much in terms of features and technology, the 2018 Highlander Hybrid is an excellent choice. It offers impressive fuel efficiency thanks to its hybrid powertrain, along with a comfortable interior and a range of available features. While it’s more expensive than non-hybrid models, the fuel savings can offset the higher cost over time.
Best Overall (If Budget Allows): 2021 Toyota Highlander
If budget is not a major concern, the 2021 Highlander is a top choice. It’s part of the fourth generation, offering a modern design, a refined interior, and advanced technology and safety features. It comes standard with Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+, providing a comprehensive suite of driver assistance features. It also offers excellent fuel economy, especially with the hybrid powertrain.
Checking Vehicle History and Getting a Pre-Purchase Inspection
No matter which year of Highlander you choose, it’s crucial to check the vehicle history report and get a pre-purchase inspection. A vehicle history report, such as Carfax or AutoCheck, can reveal potential problems like accidents, title issues, and odometer fraud. A pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic can identify any mechanical issues that may not be apparent during a test drive. These steps can help you avoid buying a lemon and ensure that you’re getting a reliable vehicle.
Conclusion: The Best Used Highlander is the One That Meets Your Needs
Ultimately, the “best” year of used Toyota Highlander to buy depends on your individual needs, budget, and priorities. By understanding the different generations, considering key factors like safety, fuel economy, and technology, and performing thorough due diligence, you can find the perfect used Highlander that fits your lifestyle and provides years of reliable service.
What are the most reliable Toyota Highlander years to consider when buying used?
Generally, Toyota Highlanders from the 2010-2013 model years, and those from 2017 onwards are considered the most reliable. These years have fewer reported issues related to engine, transmission, or other major components compared to other model years. Owners report higher satisfaction and lower maintenance costs, making them a safer bet when purchasing a used vehicle.
Conversely, some model years to be cautious of include 2008, 2014, and 2015. These years have been associated with potential problems, such as excessive oil consumption, transmission issues, or infotainment system glitches. While individual vehicles may vary, these years require more thorough inspection before purchase.
What are some common problems to look for when inspecting a used Toyota Highlander?
Before purchasing a used Toyota Highlander, meticulously inspect for excessive oil consumption, especially in models from the early 2010s. Also, pay close attention to the transmission, ensuring smooth shifting between gears and listening for any unusual noises or vibrations. Check the functionality of the infotainment system, especially in models with more advanced features, as these can sometimes exhibit software glitches.
Beyond mechanical issues, scrutinize the vehicle’s history for any signs of accidents or flood damage. Check the Carfax or similar vehicle history reports. Examine the undercarriage for rust, particularly if the vehicle was driven in regions with harsh winters and salted roads. Finally, thoroughly test all electronic components, including power windows, locks, and the air conditioning system.
What is the typical price range for a used Toyota Highlander, and how does the year affect the price?
The price range for a used Toyota Highlander varies significantly depending on the year, mileage, condition, and trim level. Generally, you can expect to find older models (pre-2010) for under $10,000, while newer models (2017 and newer) can range from $25,000 to $40,000 or more. The Kelley Blue Book and Edmunds websites are excellent resources for current market values.
The year is a primary driver of price. Newer models with lower mileage and updated features will naturally command a higher price. However, even within the same year, the trim level (LE, XLE, Limited) and optional features can significantly impact the asking price. Always compare similar vehicles to ensure you’re getting a fair deal.
Which Toyota Highlander trim levels offer the best value for the money when buying used?
The XLE trim level often strikes a good balance between features and price, making it a popular choice for used Highlander buyers. It typically includes leather upholstery, a sunroof, heated front seats, and a power liftgate, providing a comfortable and convenient driving experience without the premium price tag of the Limited trim.
While the base LE trim is more affordable, it lacks some of the desirable features found in the XLE. The Limited trim offers the most luxurious features, but the price premium may not be justified for all buyers. Ultimately, the best value depends on your individual needs and budget, but the XLE trim provides a solid combination of features and affordability.
Are there any specific engine types or drivetrain configurations to prefer or avoid in a used Toyota Highlander?
The V6 engine, available in most Highlander models, is generally considered more reliable and powerful than the four-cylinder option. While the four-cylinder may offer slightly better fuel economy, the V6 provides better performance for hauling cargo or driving in hilly terrain. It also tends to have a longer lifespan with proper maintenance.
Regarding drivetrain, the all-wheel-drive (AWD) configuration is beneficial if you live in an area with frequent snow or inclement weather. However, if you primarily drive in dry conditions, the front-wheel-drive (FWD) option will be more fuel-efficient. Both drivetrains are generally reliable, so the choice depends on your specific driving needs.
What maintenance records should I look for when buying a used Toyota Highlander?
Comprehensive maintenance records are crucial when purchasing any used vehicle, including a Toyota Highlander. Look for evidence of regular oil changes, tire rotations, and other routine maintenance items performed according to the manufacturer’s recommended schedule. These records demonstrate that the previous owner took good care of the vehicle.
Pay particular attention to records of any major repairs or replacements, such as transmission service, brake work, or suspension repairs. These records can provide insight into the vehicle’s overall condition and potential future maintenance needs. If maintenance records are unavailable, consider having a pre-purchase inspection performed by a qualified mechanic.
How does mileage affect the reliability and lifespan of a used Toyota Highlander?
Higher mileage generally indicates more wear and tear on a vehicle, potentially increasing the risk of future repairs. However, a well-maintained Toyota Highlander with higher mileage can still be a reliable choice, especially if it has a documented history of regular maintenance and timely repairs. Proper maintenance is often more important than mileage alone.
Conversely, a lower-mileage Highlander that has been neglected or poorly maintained may be less reliable than a higher-mileage vehicle with a thorough maintenance history. Always prioritize a comprehensive inspection and a review of maintenance records over simply focusing on the odometer reading. Consider the overall condition and history of the vehicle, not just the mileage.