The Toyota Highlander has been a staple in the mid-size SUV market for over two decades, consistently praised for its reliability, practicality, and family-friendly features. With so many model years available, choosing the “best” one can feel overwhelming. This guide aims to break down the strengths and weaknesses of different generations, helping you determine which Highlander year best suits your needs and budget. We will cover aspects like reliability, features, performance, and value for money, offering a comprehensive analysis to inform your decision.
A Look at the Highlander’s Generations
The Toyota Highlander has gone through four distinct generations, each bringing its own set of improvements and innovations. Understanding these generations is crucial for identifying the best year for you. Each generation has different strengths and weaknesses.
First Generation (2001-2007): The Original Crossover
The first generation Highlander, introduced in 2001, was a game-changer. It offered a car-like driving experience with the practicality of an SUV, making it a popular choice for families. It was available with either a four-cylinder or a V6 engine, providing options for fuel economy and power. These models are known for their dependability and longevity, making them a solid choice for budget-conscious buyers.
Early models (2001-2003) offered a more compact size, appealing to those who preferred a smaller vehicle. Later models (2004-2007) received a facelift and some interior updates, improving their overall appeal. However, features like navigation and advanced safety systems were less common or unavailable in this generation. The first generation established the Highlander as a reliable and practical choice.
Second Generation (2008-2013): Growing Up
The second generation Highlander grew in size, offering more space for passengers and cargo. It featured a more modern design and improved safety features. The V6 engine became the standard, providing more power and refinement. A hybrid version was also introduced, offering better fuel economy. This generation is known for its spaciousness and comfortable ride.
Models from 2011-2013 received a mid-cycle refresh, updating the exterior styling and adding new features. These later models offer a slightly more modern feel. However, some owners have reported issues with the automatic transmission in certain years. Consider a pre-purchase inspection to identify potential problems. Overall, the second generation offered a significant step up in terms of size, comfort, and features.
Third Generation (2014-2019): Modern Refinement
The third generation Highlander brought a significant redesign, with a more stylish exterior and a more refined interior. It offered improved fuel economy, enhanced safety features, and updated technology. The V6 engine was paired with a new eight-speed automatic transmission, improving performance and efficiency. This generation is highly regarded for its modern features, comfortable interior, and strong resale value.
The 2017 model year received a facelift, adding a new front fascia, updated taillights, and additional safety features like Toyota Safety Sense. This update makes the 2017-2019 models particularly desirable. This generation offers a good balance of practicality, technology, and style. It represents a significant upgrade over previous generations.
Fourth Generation (2020-Present): Technology and Efficiency
The fourth generation Highlander features a bold new design, a more refined interior, and the latest technology. It’s built on Toyota’s New Global Architecture (TNGA-K) platform, which improves ride quality and handling. The hybrid version offers excellent fuel economy. This generation boasts the most advanced features and a modern driving experience.
The 2023 model year saw the introduction of a new turbocharged four-cylinder engine, replacing the V6 in many trims. While some may miss the V6, the turbo-four offers similar power and improved fuel efficiency. This generation emphasizes technology, safety, and fuel efficiency. It’s the most modern and feature-rich Highlander to date.
Evaluating the Best Highlander Years: Key Considerations
Determining the best Highlander year requires considering several factors. These include reliability, safety, features, fuel economy, and price. Each factor plays a role in the overall ownership experience.
Reliability: A Highlander Hallmark
The Toyota Highlander is renowned for its reliability. However, certain years have proven more reliable than others. Examining common problems and owner reviews can help identify the most dependable models. Highlander models generally have above average reliability ratings.
First and second-generation Highlanders are known for their simple, robust designs, which contribute to their reliability. However, older models may require more maintenance due to their age. Third-generation Highlanders generally have fewer reported issues than earlier generations. The fourth generation is still relatively new, but early reports suggest good reliability. Before purchasing any used vehicle, a thorough inspection by a qualified mechanic is always recommended.
Safety: Protecting Your Family
Safety is a crucial consideration for any family vehicle. The Highlander has consistently earned high safety ratings from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). The Highlander’s focus on safety makes it a great family vehicle.
Later models offer advanced safety features like automatic emergency braking, lane departure warning, and adaptive cruise control. The Toyota Safety Sense suite, which includes many of these features, became standard on the Highlander starting in 2017. Older models may lack these advanced safety technologies. Review the safety ratings and features of each model year to ensure it meets your safety requirements.
Features and Technology: Staying Connected
The Highlander’s features and technology have evolved significantly over the years. Newer models offer advanced infotainment systems, smartphone integration, and driver-assistance features. Older models may lack these modern conveniences. Features are an important thing to consider when buying a vehicle.
The third and fourth-generation Highlanders offer a wide range of features, including touchscreen displays, navigation systems, and premium audio systems. Consider your technology needs when choosing a Highlander year. If you value the latest gadgets and connectivity features, a newer model will likely be a better fit. Models from 2017 and newer are more likely to include Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
Fuel Economy: Balancing Power and Efficiency
Fuel economy is an important consideration for many buyers. The Highlander offers a range of engine options, including four-cylinder, V6, and hybrid powertrains. The hybrid models offer the best fuel economy, but they also come at a higher price. The Highlander offers great fuel economy for an SUV.
The first-generation Highlander with the four-cylinder engine offers the best fuel economy among the non-hybrid models. The V6 engines provide more power but consume more fuel. The hybrid models, introduced in the second generation, offer a significant improvement in fuel economy. The fourth-generation hybrid models are particularly efficient. Consider your driving habits and fuel costs when choosing an engine option.
Price and Value: Getting the Most for Your Money
The price of a used Highlander varies depending on the year, condition, and mileage. Older models are more affordable, but they may require more maintenance. Newer models offer more features and technology, but they come at a higher price. The Highlander is known for having great resale value.
Consider your budget and priorities when choosing a Highlander year. A well-maintained first or second-generation Highlander can be a great value for budget-conscious buyers. A third-generation Highlander offers a good balance of features, reliability, and price. A fourth-generation Highlander provides the latest technology and a modern driving experience, but it’s the most expensive option. Research current market values to ensure you’re getting a fair price.
Specific Year Recommendations
Based on the factors discussed above, here are some specific Highlander year recommendations:
- Best Value (Budget-Friendly): 2006-2007 Highlander. These models offer good reliability and are available at affordable prices. They are easy to maintain and offer a comfortable ride.
- Best Overall (Balance of Features and Price): 2017-2019 Highlander. These models offer a modern design, updated safety features, and good fuel economy. They also have strong resale value. The Toyota Safety Sense package is a great addition.
- Best for Fuel Economy (Hybrid): 2020 or newer Highlander Hybrid. These models offer excellent fuel economy and the latest technology. The fourth-generation hybrid is the most efficient Highlander ever produced.
- Best for Technology (Latest Features): 2023 Highlander. The fourth generation offers the latest tech and design.
Potential Issues and Considerations
Even the reliable Toyota Highlander has some potential issues to be aware of. Researching common problems for each model year can help you make an informed decision. This will help you when choosing the best Highlander.
- First Generation: Rust, particularly in areas with harsh winters. Check for rust on the undercarriage and around the wheel wells.
- Second Generation: Transmission issues, particularly in the early years (2008-2010). Have the transmission inspected before purchasing.
- Third Generation: Some reports of infotainment system glitches. Test the infotainment system thoroughly before purchasing.
- Fourth Generation: Relatively new, but some owners have reported issues with the new turbocharged four-cylinder engine. Monitor owner forums and reviews for any emerging problems.
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Highlander for You
Ultimately, the best year for a Toyota Highlander depends on your individual needs and priorities. Consider your budget, desired features, and driving habits when making your decision. Thoroughly research each model year and get a pre-purchase inspection before buying any used vehicle. The Toyota Highlander’s legendary reliability makes it a good investment.
With careful research and consideration, you can find a Highlander that will provide years of reliable and enjoyable transportation for you and your family. Be sure to test drive several models to get a feel for their handling and features. Comparing the pros and cons of each generation will help you narrow down your choices. Investing the time in research will ensure that you choose the best Highlander for your specific needs.
Long-Term Ownership Considerations
Beyond the initial purchase, consider the long-term costs associated with owning a Highlander. This includes maintenance, repairs, and insurance. The Highlander is known for its relatively low maintenance costs.
- Maintenance: Regular oil changes, tire rotations, and other routine maintenance are essential to keep your Highlander running smoothly.
- Repairs: While the Highlander is generally reliable, unexpected repairs can occur. Factor in potential repair costs when budgeting for ownership.
- Insurance: Insurance rates vary depending on the model year, your driving record, and your location. Get quotes from multiple insurers to find the best rate.
Keeping these long-term considerations in mind will help you make a more informed decision and ensure that you’re prepared for the financial aspects of owning a Toyota Highlander. A well-maintained Highlander can provide years of reliable service with minimal issues.
What are the key factors to consider when determining the “best” year for a Toyota Highlander?
The “best” year for a Toyota Highlander is subjective and depends largely on your individual needs and budget. Consider factors such as reliability ratings from sources like Consumer Reports and J.D. Power, safety features available in different model years (including driver-assistance technologies), fuel efficiency, and the specific trim levels that offer the features you desire, like leather seats, upgraded audio systems, or advanced navigation. Thinking about your priorities, such as cargo space, passenger capacity, or towing capability, will also help narrow down the field.
Another important aspect is the Highlander’s history of recalls and common problems. Researching these issues for specific model years will help you avoid potential headaches and costly repairs down the road. Furthermore, compare the cost of ownership, including maintenance, insurance, and depreciation, across different years to ensure the vehicle aligns with your budget. Finally, test drive Highlanders from a few different model years to experience the driving dynamics and comfort levels firsthand.
Which Toyota Highlander years are generally considered the most reliable?
Toyota Highlanders are known for their reliability, and several model years consistently score high in reliability ratings. Specifically, the 2017-2019 models from the third generation are often cited as particularly reliable, as are models from the 2020 onward fourth generation. These years tend to have fewer reported issues and lower overall repair costs compared to other model years.
However, even within these reliable years, it’s crucial to check the specific vehicle’s history through a vehicle identification number (VIN) search. This will reveal any past accidents, maintenance records, and recall notices. Before purchasing any used vehicle, a pre-purchase inspection by a trusted mechanic is always recommended, regardless of its reputation for reliability, to ensure there are no hidden problems.
Are there any specific Toyota Highlander years to avoid, and why?
While the Highlander generally boasts a strong reputation, certain model years have reported more issues than others. The 2008-2010 models from the second generation, particularly those with the 3.5L V6 engine, have been known to experience oil cooler line failures, leading to engine damage. Additionally, some owners have reported issues with the 2014-2016 models, including transmission problems and excessive oil consumption.
It’s important to note that not all vehicles from these years will experience these problems. However, the higher frequency of reported issues warrants extra caution and thorough inspection before purchasing. Researching owner forums and checking for specific technical service bulletins related to these years is highly recommended to be aware of potential problems.
What are the main differences between the Toyota Highlander generations?
The Toyota Highlander has undergone several redesigns, resulting in distinct generations with notable differences. The first generation (2001-2007) was smaller and more car-like, focusing on comfort and fuel efficiency. The second generation (2008-2013) grew in size, offering more passenger and cargo space, and introduced a hybrid option.
The third generation (2014-2019) further refined the Highlander with a more modern design, improved fuel economy, and advanced safety features. The fourth generation (2020-present) boasts a bolder exterior, a more luxurious interior, enhanced technology, and a redesigned platform for better handling and ride quality. Each generation builds upon the strengths of its predecessor, offering different levels of refinement and features.
How does the hybrid option impact the “best” year decision for a Toyota Highlander?
The Toyota Highlander Hybrid offers significant advantages in fuel efficiency and reduced emissions, making it a compelling choice for environmentally conscious buyers. However, hybrid models typically come with a higher initial price tag, which may affect your budget. When considering the “best” year, weigh the long-term fuel savings against the upfront cost and potential maintenance costs of the hybrid system.
Hybrid battery life is a crucial consideration. While Toyota hybrid batteries are generally reliable, they do eventually need replacement, which can be a significant expense. Research the warranty coverage for the hybrid system in different model years and factor in the expected battery lifespan. Also, consider that hybrid models might have slightly different driving dynamics compared to their gasoline-only counterparts.
What safety features are important to consider when choosing a Toyota Highlander?
Safety features are paramount when selecting any vehicle, and the Toyota Highlander offers a range of them across different model years. Look for features like Toyota Safety Sense, which typically includes pre-collision systems, lane departure alert, adaptive cruise control, and automatic high beams. These features can significantly enhance driver awareness and reduce the risk of accidents.
Consider the availability of blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, and parking sensors, especially if you frequently drive in urban environments or have difficulty maneuvering in tight spaces. Also, check the crash test ratings from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) for different model years to ensure the vehicle provides adequate protection in the event of a collision.
How do trim levels influence the “best” year decision for a Toyota Highlander?
Toyota Highlanders are available in various trim levels, each offering a different combination of features and amenities. The trim level you choose will significantly impact your overall satisfaction with the vehicle. For example, the base “L” trim typically offers essential features, while higher trims like “Limited” or “Platinum” include leather seats, premium audio systems, panoramic sunroofs, and advanced technology features.
When deciding on the “best” year, consider which trim level best suits your needs and budget. If you prioritize luxury and convenience, you might need to focus on newer models with higher trim levels. However, if you’re primarily concerned with reliability and affordability, an older model with a lower trim level might be a more sensible choice. Carefully compare the features offered in each trim level for different model years to make an informed decision.