The Toyota Highlander has long held a reputation as a reliable, family-friendly SUV that blends comfort, technology, and Toyota’s renowned dependability. As a popular choice in the midsize SUV segment, it’s commonly driven for years, making long-term affordability—especially maintenance costs—a crucial consideration for owners and potential buyers alike.
This article dives deep into the question, “Is Toyota Highlander expensive to maintain?” We’ll explore various aspects of ownership including the average maintenance costs, recommended service intervals, common issues, and how the Highlander compares to similar SUVs in terms of reliability and maintenance expenses. Whether you’re considering leasing, buying used, or have just taken ownership, this detailed guide will help you understand what to expect in terms of upkeep and budgeting.
Understanding Maintenance Costs
To determine whether the Toyota Highlander is expensive to maintain, it’s important to break maintenance into two categories: routine maintenance and major repair costs.
Routine Maintenance
Routine maintenance is required to keep your vehicle running efficiently and prevent costly breakdowns. It includes oil changes, tire rotations, brake inspections, and fluid replacements.
- Oil Change – Typically every 5,000–10,000 miles depending on conditions and oil type. Average cost: $30–$80.
- Brake Pads Replacement – Usually needed every 30,000–70,000 miles. Average cost: $100–$300 per axle.
- Transmission Fluid Change – Recommended every 90,000 miles. Average cost: $150–$300.
- Tire Rotation – Every 5,000–7,500 miles. Average cost: $20–$50.
- Air Filter Replacement – Every 15,000–30,000 miles. Average cost: $20–$50.
- Spark Plugs – Every 30,000–60,000 miles. Average cost: $30–$120 depending on number of cylinders.
Major Repair Costs
Major repair costs are typically associated with wear and tear over time, malfunctions, and unexpected breakdowns.
Some of these more expensive repairs include:
- Timing Belt Replacement – Around $500–$900 (if the model is equipped with it).
- Water Pump Replacement – If replaced separately, $300–$750.
- Transmission Repairs – $1,200–$3,000+
- Replacing Alternator – $350–$800
- Rebuild or Replace Engine – $2,500–$5,500+
Toyota Highlander Maintenance Schedule
Toyota provides a comprehensive maintenance schedule, typically based on time intervals or mileage—whichever comes first. Owners are advised to follow the Toyota Maintenance Schedule, outlined in the owner’s manual, as failing to do so can result in higher costs later.
For the 2020 Toyota Highlander (as a reference model), the schedule is as follows:
| Mileage Interval | Recommended Service |
|---|---|
| 5,000 miles / 6 months | Oil change, tire rotation, multi-point inspection, fluid checks. |
| 15,000 miles | Air filter replacement (cabin and engine), brake inspection, belt inspection. |
| 30,000 miles / 36 months | Spark plug replacement, coolant inspection/drain/refill, fuel filter inspection. |
| 60,000 miles / 72 months | Differential fluid change, timing belt inspection, brake fluid flush, transmission fluid change. |
| 90,000 miles / 96 months | Replace all fluids, timing belt if necessary, power steering flush. |
Note: Some maintenance, like brake fluid and transmission fluid changes, might not be necessary at that mileage unless signs of wear are present. Also, newer hybrid models may have a somewhat different maintenance schedule. Always refer to the owner’s manual or your Toyota dealership for tailored recommendations.
Toyota Highlander Maintenance Compared to Similar SUVs
To understand whether the Highlander is expensive to maintain, comparing it to other vehicles within its class is useful. Below is a comparative look with some popular midsize SUVs.
Maintenance Costs Table by Vehicle
| Model | Average Annual Maintenance Cost | 10-Year Maintenance Estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Toyota Highlander | $350 – $450 | $3,500 – $4,500 |
| Honda Pilot | $400 – $500 | $4,000 – $6,000 |
| Hyundai Palisade | $300 – $400 | $3,000 – $4,800 |
| Jeep Grand Cherokee | $500 – $700 | $5,000 – $8,500 |
| Ford Explorer | $450 – $550 | $4,800 – $7,000 |
The Highlander’s maintenance costs generally align well with its reliability. It comes as no surprise that the Toyota is frequently cited for excellent reliability and competitive upkeep.
Reliability: A Major Cost-Saving Factor
One of the most compelling reasons why the Toyota Highlander remains a top-selling SUV is its long-term reliability. According to the J.D. Power 2023 Initial Quality Study, Toyota ranks near the top in vehicle dependability and owner satisfaction.
Reliability plays direct influence on maintenance costs. Vehicles prone to mechanical problems or faulty electronics often lead to higher repair volumes, whereas reliable vehicles tend to need fewer unscheduled visits to the shop.
Longevity and High Mileage Performance
Toyota Highlanders are well known to easily surpass 200,000 miles with proper maintenance. This longevity significantly affects ownership cost calculations.
In real-world owner reports, many Highlanders reach up to 250,000 miles without major breakdowns if regular oil changes, fluid replacements, and belt checks are attended to.
Consumer Reports Reliability Ratings
Consumer Reports consistently awards the Toyota Highlander high marks. For 2021–2022 models, reliability ratings averaged above 4 out of 5, which is considered outstanding compared to industry norms.
High ratings correlate with fewer repairs, fewer recalls, and high owner confidence in maintenance predictability—all factors that indicate lower costs.
Common Problems and Recalls
Even the most reliable vehicles aren’t completely problem-free, and the Toyota Highlander is no exception. Here are some common issues reported by owners:
Hybrid-Specific Maintenance
Battery Degradation
A common concern with second-generation and later hybrid models (starting around 2014–2017) is battery pack degradation or cooling system faults.
- Average hybrid battery replacement cost: $2,800–$4,200 (at non-dealership shops)
- Dealership cost (with warranty availability): Potentially lower if manufacturer warranty applies
However, most hybrid owners report that battery longevity often surpasses 10 years or 150,000 miles.
Electronic and Infotainment Issues
Starting with the 2013 model year, Toyota introduced a new infotainment system across its lineup, including the Highlander. While user-friendly, issues have been reported, such as:
- System crashes
- Slow response or touch-screen failure
- Bluetooth pairing issues
These issues usually appear after 80,000–100,000 miles and could cost $300–$1,000 to replace or update depending on the model and shop.
Timing Chain Problems in 2008–2010 Models
Certain 2008–2010 Highlanders with the 3.5L V6 engine experienced premature timing chain wear. While not reported in later model years, if purchasing older used models, it’s essential to verify this issue has been addressed.
Recalls and Repair Assistance
Toyota often addresses technical issues proactively through recalls or technical service bulletins (TSBs). Some notable Highlander recalls include:
- 2008–2010: Engine Control Module Fault – Addressed via ECU reflash.
- 2013–2014: Brake Hose Design Flaw – Replaced at no cost under recall.
- 2020–2021: Rearview Camera Delay Issue – Toyota provided a software fix.
Owners can check for open recalls directly on Toyota’s official recall webpage using their vehicle’s VIN.
DIY vs. Dealership: Finding Cost-Saving Opportunities
Another major factor influencing the cost of maintaining a Toyota Highlander is the choice of where maintenance is performed—dealerships versus independent shops or even DIY methods.
Dealership Maintenance
Going to a Toyota dealership ensures access to genuine OEM parts, manufacturer-trained technicians, and compliance with warranty terms (if under warranty). However, dealership service tends to be more expensive.
- Oil change at dealership: $50–$80
- Minor diagnostics: $100–$180
- Major service (e.g., transmission fluid change): $250–$300
Independent Auto Shops
Many reputable independent mechanics and service centers can perform proper maintenance and diagnostics. This often offers a cost savings of 20% to 40%.
- Oil change: $30–$60
- Brake job: $90–$200
- Transmission flush: $150–$200
Ensure the workshop has experience with Toyota models and preferably certified ASE technicians.
DIY Maintenance
For experienced owners, doing some basic maintenance at home—like oil changes or cabin air filter replacements—can further reduce costs.
Estimated DIY Savings Per Year
| Maintenance Task | DIY Cost | Dealership Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Oil Change (5 times/year) | $50 | $350 |
| Cabin Air Filter | $20 | $120 |
| Engine Air Filter | $15 | $80 |
| Headlight Bulbs | $25 | $125 |
Savings can easily reach $500 annually for hands-on owners. However, DIY isn’t ideal for major system issues like hybrid battery replacement or timing chain work.
Extended Warranty Programs
Purchasing an extended warranty for your Toyota Highlander—especially if buying used—can be a wise investment. Warranties such as Toyota Care (which includes two years of scheduled maintenance and 3-year/36,000-mile basic warranty) add value and limit long-term costs.
Types of Extended Warranty Options
- Manufacturer Warranty (Toyota Direct) – Typically reliable, but pricier. Good for hybrid systems and high-cost repairs.
- Third-Party Warranties – Offered through dealers or online providers. May be more affordable, but coverage varies significantly. Always check reviews before selecting one.
- Powertrain-Only Plans – Cheaper and ideal for older vehicles where only major repairs are needed.
Tips to Keep Toyota Highlander Maintenance Costs Low
Maintaining your Highlander affordably doesn’t only come down to brand reliability. It also involves smart driving and preventative habits.
1. Follow Toyota’s Scheduled Maintenance Plan
Stay on schedule with oil changes, inspections, and fluid replacements. This keeps small issues from developing into costly repairs.
2. Use Genuine Toyota Parts or Reputable Aftermarket Equivalents
Some owners opt for genuine OEM parts during major repairs to ensure proper performance and system compatibility.
3. Learn Basic DIY Skills
Check tire pressure regularly, inspect fluid levels, and replace wiper blades and filters yourself to save labor fees.
4. Monitor Dashboard Warning Lights
Early identification of a check engine light or hybrid system fault can prevent hefty charges later.
5. Maintain Vehicle Cleanliness
Keep your Highlander’s interior and exterior clean to preserve integrity of materials and make inspection easier.
Real-World Owner Insights
A valuable source of data comes directly from real-world owners who have driven over 150,000 miles in their Toyota Highlanders. Here are some trends observed from owner forums and sites like Edmunds, Kelley Blue Book, and Reddit:
- “Ran my third-gen (2008) Highlander up to 190k miles—spent about $500 total on maintenance that wasn’t covered by warranty,” writes one KBB forum user.
- “Maintenance is smooth and predictable,” reports another 2016 Highlander hybrid owner. “Just $400/year on average.”
- “Had my 2010 timing chain fixed under a TSB. Free of charge—proof Toyota stands by their models,” shared a member of Toyota Nation forum.
Conclusion: Is Toyota Highlander Expensive to Maintain?
When evaluating the question: Is Toyota Highlander expensive to maintain?, the clear answer based on comprehensive research and real-world reports is no—it is not particularly expensive to maintain, especially compared to other midsize SUVs in the market.
Thanks to its proven reliability, a well-supported dealership network, manageable service schedule, and relatively affordable parts and labor, the Highlander’s owners are often rewarded with predictable and moderate ongoing costs. Additionally, its impressive longevity allows the cost per mile of ownership to decrease further over time.
Whether choosing the hybrid or standard gas-powered variant, the Toyota Highlander remains a well-rounded option that brings family-oriented comfort without the worry of recurring costly breakdowns.
Ultimately, with due diligence and proper maintenance practices, your Highlander can continue to serve you reliably and affordably for many years and tens of thousands of miles.
About the Author
This article was written using extensive information gathered from verified sources, including automotive experts from Edmunds, Kelley Blue Book, Consumer Reports, and owner forums. The goal was to provide a balanced, well-researched look into maintenance costs to help future and current Toyota Highlander owners make informed decisions.
What is the average annual maintenance cost for a Toyota Highlander?
The average annual maintenance cost for a Toyota Highlander is typically between $300 and $500, depending on the vehicle’s age, mileage, and the specific services required. This range accounts for regular maintenance tasks such as oil changes, tire rotations, brake inspections, and fluid checks. Compared to other midsize SUVs in its class, the Highlander is considered economical to maintain, especially when routine maintenance is performed on schedule to prevent costly repairs.
Additional factors that can influence annual costs include the location of the service center, labor rates, and whether repairs are done at a dealership or an independent shop. Routine services like replacing air filters, belts, and hoses can also impact the overall maintenance budget. Owners who perform regular upkeep tend to experience fewer unexpected repair bills, which contributes to the Highlander’s reputation for reliability and cost-effectiveness.
How does the Toyota Highlander’s reliability affect its maintenance costs?
The Toyota Highlander has long been recognized for its above-average reliability ratings, which significantly contribute to lower long-term maintenance expenses. High reliability reduces the likelihood of unexpected mechanical failures, meaning fewer costly repairs over time. Toyota’s reputation for building durable vehicles means that many owners can go years without major service interventions.
Additionally, reliability ensures that the vehicle retains its value better and requires fewer part replacements compared to less dependable models. Many components of the Highlander are designed to last tens of thousands of miles, allowing for extended service intervals. This reliability factor ultimately results in predictable and manageable maintenance costs, especially when compared to less reliable competitors or luxury SUVs.
Are Toyota dealerships more expensive for maintenance than independent shops?
Toyota dealerships often charge higher labor rates than independent shops, which can make some services more expensive. However, dealerships provide certified technicians, genuine Toyota parts, and specialized diagnostic tools that are specifically designed for the Highlander’s systems. This can be particularly beneficial when dealing with complex issues or warranty-covered repairs.
Independent shops, on the other hand, may offer lower labor rates and a more personalized experience, but it’s essential to ensure they have experience with Toyota vehicles. Choosing a qualified independent mechanic can reduce costs, especially for routine maintenance tasks like oil changes and tire rotations. Ultimately, the decision depends on the type of service needed, the owner’s comfort level, and whether the vehicle is still under warranty.
What are the most common repairs for Toyota Highlander vehicles?
While the Highlander is a reliable vehicle, some common repairs have been reported over time. These include issues with the infotainment system, such as touchscreen malfunctions or connectivity problems. Additionally, some owners have experienced problems with the automatic transmission, particularly shuddering or unusual noises when shifting gears. These repairs can range from minor software updates to more involved mechanical fixes.
Other commonly reported repairs involve suspension components like struts and shocks, as well as water leaks due to clogged drain tubes. Electrical issues, including malfunctioning power windows or air conditioning systems, have also appeared in some model years. While not all Highlanders experience these issues, regular inspections and prompt attention to early warning signs can reduce the likelihood and severity of these repairs.
How often should I service my Toyota Highlander to keep maintenance costs low?
To keep maintenance costs low, it’s recommended to follow Toyota’s scheduled maintenance plan, which typically includes services every 5,000 to 10,000 miles depending on driving conditions. Routine tasks such as oil changes, tire rotations, brake inspections, and fluid checks help identify and resolve issues before they escalate. Adhering to the schedule also helps maintain the vehicle’s performance and fuel efficiency.
As the vehicle accumulates mileage, timing belt replacement around 90,000 miles, transmission fluid changes, and coolant flushes become important. These services are more involved but are critical to the Highlander’s long-term reliability. Regular service not only prolongs the vehicle’s life but also helps avoid costly breakdowns by addressing components that wear over time.
Are parts for the Toyota Highlander expensive or difficult to find?
Toyota parts for the Highlander are generally not expensive and are widely available through both dealerships and aftermarket suppliers. Since the Highlander is a popular model, many commonly needed components like brake pads, oil filters, and wiper blades are readily stocked by local auto parts stores or online retailers. Aftermarket options can provide cost savings for routine maintenance and simple repairs.
For more complex or high-tech components—such as transmissions, sensors, or the hybrid battery in hybrid models—genuine Toyota parts are often recommended to ensure proper performance and compatibility. While some parts may be more expensive, their availability remains strong due to Toyota’s extensive dealer and supplier network. Owning a Highlander means you’re unlikely to face significant delays or premium costs related to parts.
Can regular maintenance extend the life of a Toyota Highlander and reduce costs?
Absolutely. Regular maintenance is key to extending the life of a Toyota Highlander and minimizing long-term costs. Routine services, such as oil changes, transmission fluid replacements, and brake inspections, help prevent wear and tear that can lead to bigger problems. Toyota recommends following the maintenance schedule in the owner’s manual to keep the vehicle operating efficiently and safely for many years.
By staying proactive with maintenance, owners can catch issues early before they escalate into expensive repairs. For example, replacing worn brake pads early can prevent damage to rotors, and regular tire rotations help maximize tread life and fuel economy. A well-maintained Highlander can easily surpass 200,000 miles, which further justifies investing in regular service to preserve the vehicle’s reliability and maintain its resale value.