The Toyota GR86 and Subaru BRZ. Two sides of the same coin? Nearly identical twins separated at birth? However you phrase it, the debate over which of these affordable sports cars reigns supreme is one that has captivated enthusiasts since their original debut over a decade ago. Now, with the arrival of the second generation, the rivalry is hotter than ever. But, which one truly comes out on top? Let’s dive deep into a comprehensive comparison to help you decide which of these fantastic machines deserves a spot in your garage.
A Shared Foundation, Distinct Personalities
Both the GR86 and BRZ are born from a collaborative effort between Toyota and Subaru. This means they share the same core components: a responsive 2.4-liter horizontally opposed four-cylinder engine, a choice of six-speed manual or automatic transmissions, and a rear-wheel-drive layout that prioritizes driving fun. But, that’s where the similarities begin to diverge.
Under the Hood: Power and Performance
The heart of both cars is the 2.4-liter boxer engine, a significant upgrade from the previous generation’s 2.0-liter unit. This translates to a noticeable increase in power and torque, addressing one of the biggest criticisms of the original models. Expect around 228 horsepower and 184 lb-ft of torque, providing ample motivation for spirited driving.
The engine’s characteristics contribute significantly to the driving experience. The flat-four configuration keeps the center of gravity low, improving handling and stability. The engine revs eagerly, encouraging drivers to explore the upper reaches of the tachometer. Both cars offer similar acceleration, making them competitive on the road and track.
Exterior Styling: A Matter of Taste
While the overall silhouette is shared, the GR86 and BRZ boast distinct exterior design cues. Toyota opted for a more aggressive and angular look, with a larger, more prominent grille and sharper lines. Subaru, on the other hand, went for a cleaner, more refined aesthetic with a slightly smaller grille and smoother contours.
The headlights and taillights also differ between the two models. The GR86 features a more complex headlight design with integrated daytime running lights, while the BRZ sports a simpler, more traditional look. Similarly, the taillights on the GR86 are more angular, while the BRZ’s are rounded and more understated.
Ultimately, the choice between the two comes down to personal preference. Do you prefer the bolder, more aggressive styling of the GR86, or the cleaner, more refined look of the BRZ?
Interior Design and Features
Inside, the differences are more subtle. Both cars offer a driver-focused cockpit with comfortable and supportive seats. The dashboard layout is nearly identical, featuring a digital instrument cluster and an infotainment screen.
However, there are some minor variations in the trim and materials used. The GR86 might feature slightly different seat upholstery options or dashboard accents compared to the BRZ. The infotainment systems are similar in functionality, but may have different user interfaces.
Regardless of which model you choose, you can expect a functional and well-designed interior that prioritizes the driving experience. Don’t expect luxurious materials or cutting-edge technology; these cars are designed to be engaging and fun to drive, not to pamper you with creature comforts.
Driving Dynamics: Where the Differences Lie
While the engine and basic chassis are the same, Toyota and Subaru have tuned the suspension and handling characteristics differently. These subtle tweaks result in distinct driving experiences.
Suspension Tuning: A Focus on Different Strengths
Toyota aimed for a slightly sharper and more aggressive handling feel in the GR86. The suspension is tuned to be a bit stiffer, resulting in quicker turn-in and a more direct connection to the road. This can make the GR86 feel more responsive and engaging on a track or winding road.
Subaru, on the other hand, opted for a more compliant and balanced setup in the BRZ. The suspension is slightly softer, providing a more comfortable ride on rough roads. This can make the BRZ a more enjoyable daily driver, while still offering plenty of fun on a back road.
These differences are subtle, but noticeable to experienced drivers. If you prioritize ultimate cornering performance and don’t mind a slightly firmer ride, the GR86 might be your preferred choice. If you prefer a more comfortable and balanced driving experience, the BRZ could be a better fit.
Steering Feel and Feedback
The steering feel also differs slightly between the two models. Toyota’s tuning often prioritizes sharpness and responsiveness, providing a more direct connection to the front wheels. Subaru typically aims for a smoother and more progressive steering feel, prioritizing stability and predictability.
Again, the differences are subtle, but noticeable. The GR86’s steering might feel a bit more eager to turn in, while the BRZ’s steering might feel more relaxed and stable. Consider your personal preferences when evaluating the steering feel of each car.
Real-World Performance: Track vs. Street
On a track, the GR86’s stiffer suspension and more aggressive steering might give it a slight edge in terms of lap times. However, the differences are likely to be marginal, and highly dependent on the driver’s skill and driving style.
On the street, the BRZ’s more compliant suspension and smoother steering might make it a more comfortable and enjoyable daily driver. The softer suspension absorbs bumps and imperfections in the road more effectively, resulting in a less jarring ride.
Value and Availability: What to Consider
Beyond the driving experience, price and availability are important factors to consider when choosing between the GR86 and BRZ.
Pricing and Trim Levels
Both the GR86 and BRZ are priced competitively within the affordable sports car segment. The base models typically start around the same price point, while higher trim levels with additional features will command a premium.
Toyota and Subaru offer different trim levels with varying levels of equipment. These might include features such as upgraded wheels, premium audio systems, and advanced safety technologies. Research the available trim levels and options for each model to determine which one best suits your needs and budget.
Availability and Waiting Lists
Due to high demand, both the GR86 and BRZ can be difficult to find at dealerships. Waiting lists are common, and some buyers may have to wait several months to take delivery of their car.
Availability can also vary depending on your location. Certain dealerships might have a higher allocation of one model compared to the other. Contact your local Toyota and Subaru dealerships to inquire about availability and waiting times.
The Verdict: Which One is Right for You?
Ultimately, the choice between the Toyota GR86 and Subaru BRZ comes down to personal preference. Both cars offer an exceptional driving experience at an affordable price.
If you prioritize sharp handling, aggressive styling, and a more direct connection to the road, the GR86 might be the better choice for you. Its stiffer suspension and more responsive steering make it a fun and engaging track car.
If you prefer a more balanced driving experience, comfortable ride, and refined styling, the BRZ could be a better fit. Its softer suspension and smoother steering make it a more enjoyable daily driver.
Consider your driving style, personal preferences, and intended use when making your decision. Test drive both cars if possible, and pay attention to the subtle differences in handling, steering, and ride quality. Ultimately, the best choice is the one that brings you the most enjoyment behind the wheel. Both cars are fantastic sports cars, so you can’t go wrong with either one.
What are the key differences between the BRZ and GR86?
The Subaru BRZ and Toyota GR86 are virtually the same car, sharing a chassis, engine, and overall design. However, the key differences lie in their tuning and styling. The BRZ typically features a slightly softer suspension setup, prioritizing comfort and predictability, while the GR86 often boasts a stiffer suspension for a more aggressive and responsive feel. This translates to the BRZ being a bit more forgiving on less-than-perfect roads, whereas the GR86 emphasizes sharper handling.
Aesthetic distinctions also exist. The BRZ typically sports a more subdued and elegant exterior design, often with subtle curves and a refined front fascia. Conversely, the GR86 generally showcases a more aggressive and sporty appearance, frequently featuring sharper lines, a more pronounced grille, and distinctive lighting elements. These styling choices aim to appeal to slightly different consumer preferences within the same sports car market.
Which car is better for daily driving, the BRZ or the GR86?
For daily driving, the Subaru BRZ generally holds a slight advantage. Its slightly softer suspension offers a more comfortable ride over bumps and imperfections commonly found on everyday roads. This translates to less fatigue during longer commutes and a more pleasant overall driving experience when you’re not specifically seeking peak performance. The interior comfort and ergonomics are essentially identical in both cars, but the suspension tuning makes a noticeable difference.
However, the difference is not dramatic. Both the BRZ and GR86 are relatively small, sporty cars, so neither will offer the plush ride of a larger sedan or SUV. If your daily commute is primarily on smooth highways, the stiffer suspension of the GR86 might not be a significant drawback. Ultimately, personal preference plays a large role, and test driving both cars is the best way to determine which suits your daily driving needs.
Does the engine performance differ between the BRZ and GR86?
Mechanically, the engines in the BRZ and GR86 are identical; both feature a 2.4-liter naturally aspirated flat-four “boxer” engine. This engine delivers the same power output and torque figures in both models, meaning acceleration and overall performance are practically the same. There might be minuscule variations due to factory tolerances, but these differences are negligible and not discernible in everyday driving or even on a track.
While the engine itself is the same, there have been reports of slightly different engine management system (EMS) tuning between the two models in the past, potentially influencing throttle response or power delivery. However, any such variations are usually very subtle and often attributed more to individual driver perception than quantifiable data. For all practical purposes, expect identical engine performance from both the BRZ and GR86.
Are there any differences in the interior of the BRZ and GR86?
The interior designs of the Subaru BRZ and Toyota GR86 are nearly identical, sharing the same basic layout, dashboard design, and seating configuration. You’ll find the same infotainment system, gauge cluster, and overall cabin ambiance in both cars. Ergonomics are also consistent, ensuring a similar driving experience regardless of which badge you choose.
Minor differences might exist in color schemes, trim materials, or stitching patterns, depending on the specific trim level and model year. However, these are mostly cosmetic and do not significantly impact the overall feel or functionality of the interior. Ultimately, the differences are subtle and usually boil down to personal preference in aesthetics rather than substantive changes in quality or features.
Which car is better for track days, the BRZ or the GR86?
For track days, the Toyota GR86 generally has a slight edge due to its typically stiffer suspension setup. This allows for more precise handling and quicker response to driver inputs, which are highly desirable characteristics on a racetrack. The GR86’s stiffer suspension can minimize body roll and improve overall stability during cornering, allowing for faster lap times for experienced drivers.
However, the BRZ’s slightly softer suspension can also be beneficial, particularly for drivers who are newer to track driving. Its more forgiving nature can make it easier to control the car and learn the limits of traction. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your driving style and skill level. A more experienced driver might prefer the GR86’s precision, while a less experienced driver might find the BRZ more approachable.
How do the prices compare between the BRZ and GR86?
Pricing between the Subaru BRZ and Toyota GR86 is generally very similar, with minor variations depending on the trim level, optional equipment, and location. Historically, Toyota has sometimes positioned the GR86 slightly higher in price than the BRZ, but the difference is often negligible and can be influenced by market demand and dealer incentives. Both cars aim to offer excellent value in the sports car segment.
It’s always advisable to check with local dealerships for the most up-to-date pricing information and any available incentives. Be sure to compare the specific trim levels and options you’re interested in, as these can influence the final price. Ultimately, the cost of ownership, including insurance and maintenance, should also be considered when making your decision.
Are there any differences in the aftermarket support for the BRZ and GR86?
Aftermarket support for both the Subaru BRZ and Toyota GR86 is extensive and virtually identical. Given that the cars share the same core components, any performance or aesthetic upgrades designed for one model will typically fit the other. This includes everything from suspension components and exhaust systems to body kits and interior modifications.
The extensive aftermarket community ensures a wide range of options for personalizing and enhancing both cars. Whether you’re looking to improve handling, increase power, or simply customize the appearance, you’ll find a plethora of aftermarket parts and accessories available from various manufacturers. The shared platform fosters a thriving aftermarket ecosystem benefiting owners of both the BRZ and GR86.