The debate between the Subaru BRZ and the Toyota 86 has been a longstanding one among car enthusiasts, with each side presenting compelling arguments for why their preferred vehicle reigns supreme. At the heart of this debate lies a fundamental question: which of these two sports cars can claim the title of being the fastest? To delve into this query, it’s essential to understand the characteristics, performance capabilities, and design philosophies behind both the BRZ and the 86. This article aims to provide a comprehensive comparison, highlighting the key factors that influence the speed and overall driving experience of these two iconic vehicles.
Introduction to the BRZ and 86
Both the Subaru BRZ and the Toyota 86 are products of a collaborative effort between Subaru and Toyota, with the aim of creating a lightweight, rear-wheel-drive sports car that would embody the spirit of driving purity. The BRZ, sold under the Subaru brand, and the 86, initially known as the Scion FR-S before being rebranded under Toyota, share a common platform, engine, and a plethora of components. Despite their similarities, each model has undergone tweaks and refinements over the years, potentially affecting their performance.
Engine and Transmission
At the core of both vehicles is a 2.0-liter naturally aspirated boxer engine, designed to produce a balance of power and efficiency. This engine, coupled with a choice of either a 6-speed manual or a 6-speed automatic transmission, provides drivers with a engaging driving experience. The manual transmission is particularly praised for its precise and smooth shifting, which can significantly impact the speed and acceleration of the vehicle.
Performance Statistics
- Subaru BRZ: The BRZ is known for its 205 horsepower at 7,000 rpm and 156 lb-ft of torque at 6,400 rpm. These numbers translate into a 0-60 mph time of approximately 6.2 seconds for the manual version.
- Toyota 86: Similarly, the Toyota 86 boasts 205 horsepower at 7,000 rpm and 156 lb-ft of torque at 6,400 rpm, with a 0-60 mph time of about 6.4 seconds for the manual model.
Design and Aerodynamics
The design of both the BRZ and the 86 is characterized by sleek lines, a low profile, and a rear-wheel-drive configuration, all of which contribute to their agility and handling. While they share a similar silhouette, minor differences in their aerodynamic packages can influence their top speeds and acceleration. For instance, the BRZ features a slightly different front bumper design and rear spoiler compared to the 86, which might offer a marginal improvement in downforce and drag reduction.
Suspension and Handling
Both vehicles are equipped with a MacPherson strut front suspension and a double-wishbone rear suspension, tailored to provide exceptional stability and cornering capabilities. The suspension setup, along with their rear-wheel-drive layout, enables drivers to experience a more connected and responsive driving experience. The similarity in their suspension designs means that handling differences are more likely to be felt through subtle tuning variations rather than outright component differences.
Traction and Stability Control
Both the BRZ and the 86 come equipped with advanced traction control systems (TCS) and vehicle stability control (VSC), designed to intervene when the vehicle’s limits are approached, ensuring safety while allowing for spirited driving. However, for those seeking to exploit the full performance potential of their vehicle, both models offer a track mode that relaxes the intervention of these systems, allowing for more aggressive driving maneuvers.
Comparative Performance
When it comes to outright speed, both the Subaru BRZ and the Toyota 86 are closely matched. Road tests and comparisons have shown that the differences in their 0-60 mph times are minimal, with some tests indicating a slight edge to the BRZ due to its marginally better power-to-weight ratio. However, these differences are so minor that they can be overshadowed by factors such as driver skill, tire quality, and the specific trim level of the vehicle.
Real-World Driving Experience
Beyond the numbers, the driving experience offered by the BRZ and the 86 is where these vehicles truly shine. Both are designed to be driver’s cars, with an emphasis on feedback, balance, and the joy of driving. Whether cruising down a straight highway or carving through twisty roads, both the BRZ and the 86 deliver a level of engagement and satisfaction that is hard to find in more powerful but less agile vehicles.
Conclusion on Speed
In conclusion, while the Subaru BRZ might have a slight edge in terms of acceleration due to minor variations in weight distribution and aerodynamics, the difference is so minimal that it hardly detracts from the Toyota 86’s performance credentials. Both vehicles are exceptionally capable and offer a driving experience that prioritizes handling, balance, and driver engagement over outright speed.
Final Thoughts
The debate over which is faster, the BRZ or the 86, ultimately Misses the point of what these vehicles are about. They are not built to be drag strip champions but rather to deliver a pure, unadulterated driving experience. For those seeking to exploit every last bit of performance, modifications and aftermarket parts can further enhance their capabilities. However, for the average enthusiast, the choice between the BRZ and the 86 should be based on personal preference, brand loyalty, and the specific features and trim levels available, rather than a slight difference in acceleration times.
In the world of sports cars, the BRZ and the 86 stand as testaments to the joy of driving, reminders that sometimes less can be more, and that the true measure of a car’s performance lies not just in its speed, but in the experience it offers to those behind the wheel. Whether you opt for the Subaru BRZ or the Toyota 86, you’re not just buying a car – you’re investing in a driving philosophy that values connection, exhilaration, and the unbridled joy of the open road.
What are the key differences between the BRZ and 86?
The Subaru BRZ and Toyota 86 are often regarded as twin models, as they share a significant number of components, including their engine, transmission, and chassis. However, despite their similarities, both cars have distinct features that set them apart from one another. The BRZ, for instance, is often associated with Subaru’s all-wheel-drive technology, although the BRZ itself is rear-wheel drive. On the other hand, the Toyota 86, previously known as the Scion FR-S, boasts a more aggressive exterior design, particularly in its front and rear bumpers.
In terms of performance, both vehicles are equipped with a 2.0-liter boxer engine that produces 205 horsepower. Nonetheless, subtle variations in their tuning and suspension setup contribute to differing driving dynamics. For example, the BRZ tends to have a slightly softer suspension, which enhances its comfort and stability during cruising, whereas the 86’s stiffer suspension makes it more responsive and engaging for spirited driving. Although these differences may seem minor, they can greatly impact the overall driving experience and appeal to different types of drivers.
How do the BRZ and 86 compare in terms of acceleration?
Accelerating from 0 to 60 mph, both the BRZ and 86 demonstrate impressive performance, with the BRZ reaching 60 mph in approximately 6.2 seconds and the 86 achieving the same in about 6.4 seconds. These figures indicate that the BRZ has a slight edge over the 86 in terms of raw acceleration. However, it’s essential to consider that the actual performance may vary depending on factors such as the driver’s skill level, road conditions, and the specific trim level of the vehicle.
The difference in acceleration between the BRZ and 86 can be attributed to their minor variations in weight distribution and gear ratios. The BRZ’s slightly lower curb weight and optimized gear ratios enable it to accelerate more quickly than the 86. Nevertheless, the 86’s acceleration is still more than satisfactory, and its responsive throttle and precise gear shifts make it an absolute delight to drive. Additionally, both vehicles offer exceptional handling and braking capabilities, allowing drivers to confidently push their limits on twisty roads or racing circuits.
What about their top speed – which car is faster?
When it comes to top speed, both the BRZ and 86 have electronically limited top speeds of 140 mph. However, in independent tests, the BRZ has been observed to reach speeds of up to 143 mph, whereas the 86 has achieved a top speed of 142 mph. Although the difference is marginal, the BRZ appears to have a slight advantage in terms of outright top speed. It’s worth noting, though, that top speed is not the only factor that determines a car’s performance, and both vehicles offer exceptional handling and agility that make them a joy to drive.
The top speed of both vehicles is limited by their engine power and aerodynamic drag. As they approach their top speed, the force of air resistance becomes significant, and the engine’s power output is no longer sufficient to overcome this resistance. In this regard, the BRZ’s slightly more aerodynamic body shape may contribute to its higher top speed. Nevertheless, the actual top speed achieved by either vehicle will depend on various factors, including the specific trim level, tire type, and environmental conditions. Ultimately, the difference in top speed between the BRZ and 86 is relatively small and may not be a decisive factor for most buyers.
How do the BRZ and 86 handle on the track?
On a racing circuit, both the BRZ and 86 demonstrate exceptional handling capabilities, thanks to their rear-wheel-drive layout, low center of gravity, and precise steering. The BRZ, in particular, has been praised for its neutral handling and predictable behavior, making it an excellent choice for track-day enthusiasts. The 86, on the other hand, has a slightly more tail-happy nature, which can be beneficial for experienced drivers who enjoy drifting and aggressive cornering.
The track performance of both vehicles can be further enhanced with the aid of optional performance packages, which typically include features such as uprated suspension, larger brakes, and stickier tires. These upgrades can significantly improve the cars’ grip, braking, and cornering capabilities, allowing drivers to push their limits even further. However, it’s essential to note that the BRZ and 86 are designed to be balanced and forgiving, making them accessible to drivers of varying skill levels. As such, they are ideal for drivers who want to hone their track-driving skills without being overwhelmed by an overly powerful or demanding vehicle.
Are there any notable differences in their braking performance?
The braking performance of the BRZ and 86 is remarkably similar, with both vehicles featuring robust braking systems that include ventilated disc brakes at all four corners. In independent tests, the BRZ has been observed to stop from 60 mph in approximately 113 feet, while the 86 requires about 115 feet to achieve the same feat. Although the difference is minor, the BRZ appears to have a slight edge in terms of braking performance.
The superior braking performance of the BRZ can be attributed to its slightly more aggressive brake pads and optimized brake calibration. However, it’s essential to note that the actual braking distance will depend on various factors, including the driver’s skill level, road conditions, and the condition of the brake pads. Both vehicles offer exceptional braking capabilities, and their anti-lock braking systems (ABS) and electronic brakeforce distribution (EBD) work in concert to provide stable and predictable stopping performance, even in emergency situations.
How do the BRZ and 86 compare in terms of fuel economy?
In terms of fuel economy, the BRZ and 86 are remarkably similar, with both vehicles offering estimated EPA ratings of up to 24 mpg in the city and 33 mpg on the highway. However, the actual fuel economy will depend on various factors, including driving habits, road conditions, and the specific trim level of the vehicle. The BRZ’s slightly more efficient engine and optimized transmission gearing contribute to its marginally better fuel economy, particularly in city driving.
The fuel economy of both vehicles can be further improved with the aid of features such as adaptive cruise control and automatic start/stop technology. These features help reduce fuel consumption by optimizing engine performance and minimizing unnecessary fuel burn. Additionally, both vehicles offer a manual transmission option, which can be beneficial for drivers who prefer to take control of gear shifts and optimize their fuel economy. Nevertheless, the difference in fuel economy between the BRZ and 86 is relatively small, and other factors such as performance, handling, and features should take precedence when making a purchasing decision.
Which car is more reliable – the BRZ or 86?
In terms of reliability, both the BRZ and 86 have excellent track records, thanks to their robust engineering and rigorous testing. According to various reliability and satisfaction surveys, the BRZ and 86 consistently rank among the top models in their respective segments. However, the Toyota 86 has a slight edge in terms of reliability, thanks to Toyota’s reputation for building durable and long-lasting vehicles.
The reliability of both vehicles can be attributed to their simple and proven mechanical designs, which minimize the risk of component failure. Additionally, both Subaru and Toyota offer comprehensive warranty programs, including 3-year/36,000-mile basic warranties and 5-year/60,000-mile powertrain warranties. These warranties provide peace of mind for owners and help protect their investment in the event of any unexpected repairs or maintenance. Ultimately, the difference in reliability between the BRZ and 86 is relatively small, and both vehicles are excellent choices for drivers who prioritize durability and dependability.