When it comes to reliable and family-friendly SUVs, the Toyota Highlander stands out as a long-standing favorite in the U.S. market. Introduced in 2001, the Highlander has continually evolved over the years, offering better technology, improved fuel efficiency, and expanded safety features. But with nearly two decades of production and several generation updates, many consumers ask: What year of Highlander is best?
This guide digs into the best model years of the Toyota Highlander, based on reliability, value, features, and customer satisfaction. Whether you’re buying new or considering a used model, this article will help you make an informed decision by analyzing every generation and highlighting the best years to consider.
Understanding the Generations of the Toyota Highlander
The Toyota Highlander has been produced across four main generations, each with notable design and feature upgrades. Understanding these generations will help you choose the best model year based on your needs and budget.
First Generation (2001–2007)
The original Highlander was introduced at the 2000 Los Angeles Auto Show and went on sale as a 2001 model. It was positioned as a midsize crossover built on the Camry platform, offering a smooth ride and car-like handling—unusual for SUVs at the time.
- Engine options: 2.4L I4 (base) and 3.0L V6 (upgraded).
- Trims: Base, CE, LE, XLE, Limited.
- Key features: DVD navigation (in later models), sunroof, and optional third-row seating.
Reliability was a strong point during this time. However, early models had issues with transmission failures and rust in colder climates. If considering a used first-gen model, it’s best to go with late-model years (2005–2007), which improved in both build quality and reliability.
Second Generation (2008–2013)
The second-generation Highlander saw a redesigned chassis, more interior space, and improved fuel economy. This generation introduced optional all-wheel drive across all trims and expanded the hybrid lineup.
- Engine options: 3.5L V6 (gasoline), 3.5L V6 hybrid (2009 and later).
- Trims: LE, XLE, Limited, Hybrid.
- Key features: Bluetooth connectivity, XM satellite radio, standard backup camera (post-2009), and improved third-row legroom.
2011 and 2012 were particularly strong years, featuring updated safety ratings and fewer recalls. This generation also introduced Toyota’s Star Safety System, which included enhanced vehicle stability control. A used 2011–2013 Highlander offers a good mix of features and value.
Third Generation (2014–2020)
The third-gen Highlander was a bigger model, with a restyled exterior and major interior upgrades. It also marked the debut of Android Auto and Apple CarPlay support later in the generation and introduced Toyota’s Entune infotainment system.
- Engine options: 2.7L I4 (base), 3.5L V6, and hybrid variants.
- Trims: L, LE, XLE, Limited, Platinum, Hybrid Limited, and Hybrid Platinum.
- Key features: Blind Spot Monitoring, Rear Cross-Traffic Alert (Limited and Platinum), Entune App Suite, and available third-row seating for eight.
This generation was also Toyota’s first step toward electrification. The hybrid model became more refined and efficient, offering better fuel economy than the gasoline-only versions. A standout model year is 2017, known for high reliability and fewer reported issues.
Fourth Generation (2021–Present)
The fourth-generation Highlander is larger but more aerodynamic, offering improved fuel economy and a host of new tech features. It’s built on Toyota’s TNGA-K platform, which enhances ride quality and safety.
- Engine options: 2.4L Turbo (gasoline), 3.5L V6 (2021–2023), and Hybrid Max (2024–present).
- Trims: L, LE, XLE, Limited, Platinum, Hybrid LE, Hybrid XLE, Hybrid Limited, Hybrid Platinum.
- Key features: Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+, 12.3-inch touchscreen, wireless Apple CarPlay, premium JBL audio system, and available 12-passenger seating with the base 2.4L turbo engine.
The TNGA platform brings better crash test ratings and improved interior comfort. The 2022 and 2023 model years are highly recommended for optimal features, improved engines, and better reliability.
Which Years Offer the Best Value and Reliability?
Now that we’ve reviewed the four generations, let’s break it down further by specific model years to find which ones are best in terms of value, reliability, and innovation.
Best Used Highlander Years (2008–2017)
For those shopping for a used Highlander on a budget, these are the most reliable and cost-effective model years to consider:
Top Contenders:
| Model Year | Generation | Reasons to Consider |
|---|---|---|
| 2011 | Second Generation | Improved reliability vs. early models, stable resale value, better safety features. |
| 2012 | Second Generation | Minor updates over 2011 with fewer reported problems. |
| 2014 | Third Generation | Updated styling, better safety tech, and more spacious interior. |
| 2016 | Third Generation | Solid reliability record and good value in the used market. |
| 2017 | Third Generation | Lowest number of reported issues and highest customer satisfaction. |
The 2017 Highlander is often cited as one of the best in terms of all-around value and reliability. It has consistently scored high in J.D. Power ratings and Consumer Reports, and it remains a popular pick among used car buyers today.
Best New and Recent Highlander Years (2021–2024+)
For new car buyers, the most recommended models start with the fourth generation, introduced in 2021. Here’s why:
Key Attributes of 2021 and Later Models:
- TNGA-K Platform: Improves ride quality, handling, and crash test performance.
- Advanced Safety: Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ standard with features like Pedestrian Detection, Lane Tracing Assist, and Adaptive Cruise Control.
- Improved Engines: The 2021–2023 models offered a refined 3.5L V6 gas engine, while the 2024 model introduced a powerful 2.4L turbo hybrid engine.
If you’re shopping for a new Highlander, 2022 and 2023 are the best used due to their balance of features, reliability, and still-decent warranties for certified pre-owned vehicles.
The latest version, 2024 Highlander Hybrid Max, introduces a new powertrain with seating for up to 8 passengers, making it ideal for large families prioritizing tech and efficiency.
Breaking Down the Best Years by Generation
We’ll now go through each generation and highlight the most reliable and feature-rich model years.
First Generation (2001–2007): Focus on 2005–2007
Early first-gen models (2001–2004) are best avoided due to known issues like engine stalling, timing belt problems, and transmission failures. The 2005–2007 models improved with stronger interiors and minor mechanical updates.
- Best Year: 2007 – More refined, with better gas mileage (3.0L engine), improved electronics, and better resale value for its era.
Second Generation (2008–2013): 2011–2013 Recommended
The second-gen models brought about redesigned body styles and improved comfort. They also introduced hybrid variants with good fuel economy for their time.
- Best Years: 2011 and 2012 – These were the most reliable model years in the generation, with few major recalls and high customer satisfaction.
Third Generation (2014–2020): 2016–2017 Stand Out
The third generation focused on modernization. Infotainment options, improved fuel economy, and refined hybrid performance helped elevate these models.
- Best Year: 2017 – Very few problems reported, and full availability of Entune features, Toyota Safety Sense upgrades, and third-row seating options.
Fourth Generation (2021–Present): 2022–2024 Most Recommended
The latest generation saw Toyota step into a design-forward SUV with strong hybrid performance and excellent family ergonomics.
- Best Year: 2022 – Great value, high reliability rating, and packed with features like three-zone climate control, Smart Key system, and optional captain’s chairs.
- Newest and Most Feature-Rich: 2024 Highlander Hybrid Max – Offers a powerful 2.4L turbocharged hybrid with seating for up to 8, adaptive driving modes, and the latest Toyota SmartKey system.
How to Decide on the Best Year for You
Choosing the best Highlander year depends on your priorities. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:
For Budget-Conscious Buyers
If you’re working with a limited budget, consider mid-to-late second-generation models (2011–2013) or early third-gen models (2014–2016). These often fall in the $10,000–$18,000 price range for used vehicles and provide excellent value and space.
For Families Looking for Tech and Comfort
Third-generation models from 2017 and above offer a wealth of comfort and tech features at a reasonable cost. Expect standard safety technologies, Apple CarPlay, tri-zone climate control, and optional third-row seating.
For top-tier tech and modern design, go for newer models in the fourth generation, especially from 2022 and newer.
For Eco-Conscious Buyers
The hybrid variants gain more value with each generation. The hybrid models in third-gen (2014–2020) deliver reliable gas-electric performance, while fourth-gen models from 2021 onward offer significantly improved efficiency and driving dynamics.
The 2024 Highlander Hybrid Max represents the pinnacle of eco-friendly innovation in the lineup. It features better acceleration while maintaining strong MPG economy, making it ideal for long-distance drivers and commuters.
Final Thoughts: What Year of Highlander is Best?
If you’re looking for the best all-around value, performance, and comfort, the answer to what year of Highlander is best comes down to a few distinct choices:
- Used Models: 2017 Highlander (third generation) for great reliability and features in a used format.
- New Models: 2022–2023 Highlander (fourth generation) for optimal features, safety, and performance without the highest new-vehicle price tag.
- Advanced Tech and Efficiency: 2024 Highlander Hybrid Max for cutting-edge design, 8-passenger seating, and next-gen drivetrain.
No matter what year you’re considering, always have a pre-purchase inspection, check recall history, and research model-specific issues. The Toyota Highlander is one of the most reputable family SUVs, and with the right model year in hand, it can be a joy to drive and own for years to come.
By using this guide, you can confidently select the best year of Highlander that matches your lifestyle, budget, and preferences. Whether you’re shopping used or building your dream family rig, Toyota’s midsize SUV continues to deliver on its reputation for quality and durability.
What factors determine which year of Highlander is the best?
When evaluating which year of the Toyota Highlander is the best, several key factors come into play, including reliability, safety features, technology, and overall value. Toyota’s midsize SUV has evolved significantly over the years, with major redesigns occurring in model years such as 2008, 2014, and 2020. Each redesign brought notable improvements, but it’s crucial to assess reliability reports, common complaints, and owner satisfaction. For instance, some model years faced recalls or consistent mechanical issues, which can greatly impact a buyer’s experience.
Differences in trim availability, powertrain improvements, and the introduction of hybrid variants also influence which year might be best suited for a buyer. From the third-generation redesign in 2014 that improved comfort and design, to the 2020 redesign that included a more upscale interior and advanced safety features, each year has its strengths. Buyers should consider their priorities—be it fuel efficiency, cargo space, towing capacity, or tech features—when deciding the best model year to suit their lifestyle and budget.
Why is the 2020 Highlander considered one of the best years to buy?
The 2020 Toyota Highlander marked a major redesign of the vehicle, positioning it as a top choice in the midsize SUV segment. Notable upgrades included a sleeker exterior, a more sophisticated and roomy interior, and the availability of a powerful hybrid powertrain. This model year also introduced Toyota’s TSS 2.5 (Toyota Safety Sense) package, which includes features like adaptive cruise control, lane departure alert, automatic emergency braking, and more. These advancements significantly improved both safety and driving experience.
Consumer reports and reviews from the time praised the 2020 Highlander for its enhanced ride quality, improved fuel efficiency, and quiet cabin. It also offered a wide range of trims and configurations, making it versatile for various family needs. As a relatively new model, it’s likely to come with fewer maintenance issues than older versions, making it an excellent choice for buyers seeking a nearly new SUV without the full price of a brand-new vehicle.
Which earlier Highlander models are still reliable and worth considering?
Model years 2011 to 2013 have gained a strong reputation for reliability and value in the used market. These years tended to avoid major recalls and widespread complaints, offering consistent performance and durability typical of Toyota engineering. With proper maintenance, these vehicles can still perform well today, especially the second generation’s refined chassis and improved V6 engine. They also offer third-row seating and decent cargo space at a fraction of the cost of newer models.
Another reliable option is the 2015 to 2017 model years, especially the second half of that range. These vehicles benefited from updates in infotainment systems, better interior materials, and reliability enhancements after the early 2014 redesign. The 2016 and 2017 Highlanders also saw improvements in crash test ratings and optional all-wheel drive performance. These models remain solid budget-friendly choices for those seeking a dependable family SUV without the latest bells and whistles.
Are any Highlander years known for recalls or reliability issues?
Yes, some Highlander model years have faced notable concerns that potential buyers should be aware of. For example, the 2008 and 2009 models had issues with steering column failures and problems with the second-row LATCH system, prompting recalls. The 2014 model, while part of a major redesign, had reports of water pump failures in hybrid versions. Such issues can lead to expensive repairs and inconvenience if not addressed or repaired through recall procedures.
Buyers should always check the vehicle identification number (VIN) against the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) recall database and get a thorough pre-purchase inspection. While many owners of these model years experienced no issues, it’s still prudent to exercise caution. Investigating repair histories, service records, and owner forums can provide better insight into which years to approach with caution and which have received appropriate fixes from dealerships or Toyota itself.
What makes the 2014 Highlander a notable year in its history?
The 2014 Toyota Highlander was significant due to it being a complete redesign after the previous generation launched in 2007. Toyota gave the Highlander a more modern and stylish look, along with a higher level of interior refinement and improved technology features. The dashboard layout was redesigned for better usability, and new trim levels added more options for buyers seeking luxury or fuel efficiency through the hybrid variant.
This redesign also came with mechanical upgrades, including a smoother-running V6 engine and the option to include more advanced driver-assist systems for its time. The suspension was tuned for better ride comfort and stability, addressing many of the previous generation’s weaknesses. While it had some early reliability concerns, particularly in its hybrid system components, the 2014 Highlander still represents a big step forward in design and capability, making it appealing to many midsize SUV buyers.
What should buyers know about Highlander trim levels and how do they vary by year?
Trim levels across Highlander model years can impact performance, comfort, and technology. Early models (2000s) included base, LE, and XLE trims, often with an optional all-wheel-drive package. The hybrid version, introduced in the early 2000s then redesigned in 2009 and again in 2020, provided better fuel economy but at a cost premium. As the model evolved, Toyota introduced more premium trims such as the Limited and Platinum, offering added luxury, leather interior, advanced tech, and enhanced safety equipment.
Buyers need to consider the trim and how it corresponds to the model year. For instance, the 2014 redesign introduced better tech packages, navigation, and entertainment systems on higher trims. Lower trims, especially of older models, may lack features now considered essential, such as Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. When shopping used, it’s crucial to match your desired features to the trim and ensure the selected model year includes those upgrades or can be retrofitted affordably if necessary.
Does the Highlander’s hybrid version offer better value across different model years?
The Highlander Hybrid has been offered in various generations, most notably from 2006–2007, then reintroduced more successfully with the third-generation 2014 model, and further refined in the 2020 redesign. Buyers interested in fuel efficiency, environmental impact, or lower long-term running costs often prefer the hybrid version. However, the initial hybrid models faced some criticism due to slower acceleration and higher purchase prices compared to gas-only versions.
In more recent years, Toyota significantly improved the hybrid system, especially the 2020 version, which features a stronger hybrid engine combined with all-wheel drive and smoother performance. These newer hybrid versions provide better responsiveness and maintain good fuel economy without sacrificing usability. While hybrids may come with higher upfront costs, their fuel savings, durability of hybrid components, and the increasing availability of servicing options can make them a strong contender for buyers focused on value and efficiency.