Choosing the best year for a Toyota Highlander isn’t just about picking a vehicle—it’s about finding a reliable, versatile, and family-friendly SUV that can stand the test of time. With a legacy dating back to 2001, the Highlander has evolved from a modest SUV into one of the most trusted midsize crossovers on the market.
For many buyers, the question isn’t just what model to buy, but which year represents the best value, performance, and reliability. This article will help you navigate through the major generations and notable model years to determine which Toyota Highlander year is the best fit for your lifestyle and budget.
Understanding the Generations of the Toyota Highlander
The Toyota Highlander has gone through four major generations, each marked by significant redesigns or updates in technology, design, and mechanical performance. Understanding these generational shifts is essential when determining the best model year.
First Generation (2001–2007)
The first-generation Highlander laid the foundation for what would become a family favorite. It was introduced as a 2001 model and remained largely unchanged through the 2007 model year. Powered by a 3.0L V6 engine, it offered decent power and respectable gas mileage for the time. However, as the design remained static for several years, it quickly began to show its age compared to newer competitors such as the Honda Pilot and Ford Explorer.
While the early models established a strong reputation for reliability, there were notable issues, especially in the earlier years. The 2001 model had reported transmission problems, and the 2002–2004 models experienced premature rust issues in colder climates. The 2005–2007 models of this generation improved in durability and reliability. If you’re considering a pre-owned first-generation Highlander, the 2006 and 2007 models are the safest bets due to their improved features and proven reliability.
Second Generation (2008–2013)
The second-generation Highlander represented a significant leap forward. It grew in size and offered more content, including an optional third-row seat, making it a true seven-seater. Toyota also offered a hybrid variant for the first time in 2009, signaling a shift toward eco-conscious design.
This generation also introduced Toyota’s Entune infotainment system, which laid the groundwork for the brand’s more advanced systems in later years. Engine performance remained solid with a 3.5L V6 as the standard engine and a hybrid option delivering more than 30 mpg in combined driving.
While this generation saw improved tech and comfort, it wasn’t without its issues. The 2008–2010 models were associated with steering rack issues, which led to an expensive recall. By the 2012 and 2013 models, these concerns were mostly resolved, and the vehicles offered exceptional comfort and value for family buyers. For this generation, 2012 and 2013 are the strongest options.
Third Generation (2014–2019)
The third-gen Highlander embraced a more modern, refined aesthetic and introduced more advanced safety and tech features. This era also saw the popularity of three-row SUVs boom, and the Highlander benefited from updated styling and a smoother ride.
The 2014–2016 models were solid buyers’ picks, but the 2017 model year was noteworthy due to the integration of Toyota’s Safety Sense (TSS) system across all trims. This suite of driver assistance technologies included forward collision warning, lane departure alert, and adaptive cruise control—features now considered essential for modern family vehicles.
Additionally, interior materials improved significantly by 2018, and the infotainment system was more intuitive. If you’re looking at the third-gen models, 2017 through 2019 are the best years—striking a balance between value, features, and lower maintenance costs.
Fourth Generation (2020–Present)
The current, fourth-generation Highlander, introduced for the 2020 model year, marked a dramatic shift toward a more premium feel, fuel efficiency, and advanced safety tech. Toyota redesigned the Highlander from the ground up using the TNGA-K platform, which allowed for improved handling, a quieter ride, and a more refined in-cabin experience.
This generation introduced a new 2.4L turbocharged inline-four engine for gas models and a 2.5L hybrid system that boosted fuel efficiency even further without sacrificing power. The hybrid model, in particular, became one of the most fuel-efficient three-row SUVs on the market, with an EPA rating of up to 36 mpg in combined city/highway driving.
Toyota also enhanced its tech offerings, including an optional 12.3-inch touchscreen display, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, Wi-Fi connectivity, and the latest version of Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ across all models.
All models since 2020 have been well-received, with the 2021 and 2022 models receiving additional standard features, such as Blind Spot Monitoring and Rear Cross-Traffic Alert. The 2023 and 2024 models pushed the envelope further in luxury and tech, making the latest models the most appealing to modern buyers prioritizing fuel economy, comfort, and technology.
Key Considerations When Choosing the Best Year
Determining the best year for the Highlander isn’t just about selecting a generational favorite—it’s about aligning personal needs and preferences with specific model-year upgrades. Here’s a breakdown of the decision criteria:
1. Budget
If you’re on a tight budget, opting for an older, well-maintained pre-owned model might be your best bet. First-generation models (2001–2007) can often be found for $5,000–$10,000 but may come with more frequent maintenance. Second-generation models (2008–2013) are often priced between $8,000–$12,000 and deliver more advanced features with proven reliability.
Conversely, if you’re looking for the latest technology, hybrid efficiency, and modern infotainment systems, you may want to consider models from 2020 onward. However, be prepared to pay $25,000 or more, even for used versions of these recent models.
2. Reliability and Maintenance
Toyota is known for producing durable vehicles, but certain model years have reputations that stand out. The 2006, 2012, and 2017 models are among the most reliable in their generations. In this aspect, the fourth generation is the most consistent, with few reported mechanical issues and lower maintenance costs.
It’s also worth noting that newer models come with better warranties and recall protections. For example, the 2020–2024 models benefit from Toyota’s 5-year/60,000-mile warranty, and many have longer hybrid-specific coverage.
3. Technology and Safety
If you’re prioritizing advanced safety or infotainment technology, your best option is the fourth generation, particularly the 2021–2024 model years. Toyota Safety Sense is standard starting from 2020, but in 2021, the system was enhanced with improved lane-keeping assist, enhanced object detection, and more accurate cruise control.
In terms of infotainment, older models are limited to smaller screens and fewer connectivity features. Starting with the 2018 model, Entune became more user-friendly. From 2020 onward, the system supports over-the-air updates, voice-activated navigation, and improved voice recognition.
4. Hybrid Efficiency vs. Gasoline Performance
Fuel efficiency plays a key role in the Highlander’s appeal. The first-generation hybrid (2008) was groundbreaking at the time but was soon eclipsed by newer, more refined systems introduced in the fourth-generation models.
If you’re looking for the best hybrid performance from a used model, the 2013–2019 models are considered solid picks. However, the 2020–2024 hybrids are by far the most efficient, with up to 36 mpg in combined driving.
For those who prefer gasoline-only power, the 2020–2024 2.4L turbocharged engine delivers excellent power (265 hp) with decent fuel economy (23 mpg city / 29 mpg highway), making it perfect for drivers who want performance without the complexity of hybrid systems.
Comparison of Top Model Years
To help you compare the best years for the Highlander, here’s a detailed look at the standout models from each generation:
| Model Year | Generation | Key Features | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 | First | Upgraded transmission, improved reliability from early models | Budget-friendly, fewer reported issues | Outdated tech, less safety features |
| 2012 | Second | Improved fuel economy, more comfort features | Well-balanced model for family use | Minor recalls with steering rack components |
| 2017 | Third | Standard Toyota Safety Sense | Strong safety suite for its time | Lower fuel economy compared to newer models |
| 2021 | Fourth | 12.3-inch touchscreen, advanced safety, updated styling | High tech, efficient hybrid option | Higher pricing compared to earlier models |
| 2024 | Fourth | Luxury cabin, adaptive suspension, Wi-Fi capability | Top-tier tech, comfort, and hybrid efficiency | Most expensive option |
Best Highlander Years for Specific Needs
For the Budget Buyer: 2006 or 2012
If you’re looking for a reliable pre-owned Highlander without breaking the bank, the 2006 or 2012 models offer a good value. The 2006 model provides solid reliability at a very low price, while the 2012 model offers significantly better comfort and convenience features for a modest increase in cost.
For Safety-Oriented Families: 2017 or 2021
Parents prioritizing safety will find the best combination of features in the 2017 and 2021 models. The 2017 marked the introduction of standard Toyota Safety Sense (TSS), allowing drivers to avoid common accidents. The 2021 model took safety to the next level with enhancements to automatic braking, blind zone detection, and adaptive cruise control.
For Eco-Minded Drivers: 2020+ Hybrid Models
Toyota’s fourth-generation hybrid Highlander delivers up to 36 mpg in combined driving, making it the most efficient model in the lineup. Starting from 2020, the hybrid variant offers great fuel economy, low emissions, and a spacious, refined cabin.
For Tech Enthusiasts: 2023 or 2024 Models
If the latest in-car tech is important to you, look no further than the 2023 and 2024 models. These generations offer a full range of digital features, including Google Built-In, Apple CarPlay, a 12.3-inch touchscreen, and more connectivity features than any previous Highlander.
Final Verdict: So, Which Year Is the Best?
While every generation of the Toyota Highlander has its strong contenders, the answer to which year is best depends on your priorities:
- If you’re budget-conscious and satisfied with fewer modern features, the 2006 or 2012 models are great value picks.
- For families who prioritize safety, the 2017 model offers the first-generation Toyota Safety Sense system with proven performance.
- For the most efficient hybrid fuel economy and advanced features, the 2021–2024 models are the standout champions, particularly in the hybrid variant.
But when weighing all factors—reliability, technology, comfort, resale value, and safety—the 2021 Toyota Highlander stands out as the most balanced and well-rounded model year. It combines excellent fuel economy with top-tier safety, updated tech, and competitive pricing. It’s not too new to suffer from depreciation shock, and it’s not too old to have outdated systems.
However, the 2023 and 2024 models also deserve mention, especially if you’re considering a nearly new or brand-new Highlander. These models bring the most refined interior, advanced hybrid systems, and seamless connectivity features, positioning the Highlander as not just a family hauler, but a luxury-capable crossover.
Conclusion
The Toyota Highlander has continually evolved to meet the changing needs of families, and each generation has its highlight years. Whether you’re looking for a bargain on a well-maintained older model, or you want the latest in hybrid efficiency and digital tech, there’s a perfect Highlander out there for you.
When determining which year is the best, it’s important to match your priorities—be it cost, comfort, safety, or innovation—with the model years that excel in those areas. But if you’re looking for the model year that offers the best combination of all these elements, the 2021 Highlander emerges as a strong recommendation.
And as Toyota continues to refine the Highlander for future generations, one thing remains clear: the brand remains committed to delivering a reliable, versatile, and comfort-oriented SUV that families can trust for years to come.
So, if you’re in the market for a Highlander, consider your needs, budget, and preferences—and don’t forget to inspect or test drive as many models as you can. The perfect year might just be the one that feels right for you and your family.
1. What factors determine the best year for a Highlander?
The best year for a Toyota Highlander largely depends on a combination of reliability, feature availability, and overall value. Toyota has consistently improved the Highlander over the years, adding advanced safety features, better fuel efficiency, and enhanced interior comfort. Recent model years tend to offer more technological advancements and updated designs. However, older models, particularly those from 2017-2019, are often praised for their proven reliability and fewer reported issues over time.
Additionally, potential buyers should weigh the importance of hybrid options, trim levels, and budget considerations. The 2020 and 2021 models introduced a redesigned platform and a more powerful hybrid powertrain, making them popular among tech-savvy shoppers. The 2023 model offers the most up-to-date features including a larger touchscreen, improved towing capacity, and more luxurious amenities. Ultimately, the ideal year will depend on individual priorities such as budget, desired features, and vehicle history.
2. Which Highlander model years had the most reported issues?
Certain Highlander model years have been associated with mechanical and technical concerns that affect buyer satisfaction. The 2008 and 2009 models, for example, saw significant transmission problems, particularly in the V6 versions. Additionally, earlier models from 2001-2003—especially the first generation—had lower reliability ratings, with some complaints about engine performance and interior build quality. These issues have made those years less favorable for long-term ownership.
In contrast, models from 2014 to 2016 also faced some criticism, primarily regarding the 3.5L V6 engine’s fuel efficiency and a few electrical issues related to the infotainment system. However, more modern iterations have benefited from Toyota’s engineering improvements, including better manufacturing standards and updated technology. It’s important to check recall and repair history for the year you’re considering and consult owner reviews to get a full picture.
3. Why is the 2020 Highlander considered a standout model year?
The 2020 Toyota Highlander marked a significant redesign for the vehicle, introducing a more modern style, a refined interior, and a range of updated features. Toyota switched to a TNGA (Toyota New Global Architecture) platform, improving ride quality, safety, and handling dynamics. The hybrid system was also enhanced, offering better fuel economy without compromising on power. These changes positioned the 2020 Highlander at the forefront of midsize SUVs.
Moreover, the 2020 model year brought standard Toyota Safety Sense 2.0 across all trims, which includes features like lane departure alert, dynamic radar cruise control, and automatic emergency braking. Interior comfort was elevated with improved materials, a quieter cabin, and optional third-row seating. Overall, the 2020 Highlander became a pivotal year in the lineup’s evolution, appealing to families and drivers looking for versatility.
4. Are older Highlander models still worth considering?
Yes, older Highlander models can still offer great value to buyers, especially those with a limited budget or those looking for a dependable used SUV. Models from 2014 to 2019 are particularly popular for their reliability, with the 2017-2019 generations often cited as the most trouble-free used SUVs in their class. Many of these models avoided the major technical issues seen in earlier years and still delivered the Highlander’s signature versatility and solid build quality.
That said, it’s crucial to perform a thorough inspection, including a vehicle history report, maintenance records, and a mechanical evaluation. Some older models may have high mileage or signs of wear, and replacement parts might be harder to source as the models age. However, for buyers who perform this due diligence, a pre-owned Highlander can offer an excellent combination of family-friendly seating, cargo space, and dependable performance.
5. What are the best years for the Highlander Hybrid?
The best years for the Highlander Hybrid tend to be 2020 and newer, following the TNGA platform redesign and the introduction of a more advanced hybrid system. These models provide better fuel economy, a more refined ride, and improved overall performance compared to earlier hybrid versions. The 2023 and 2024 models offer the latest hybrid powertrain with smart tech and enhanced safety features built-in, making them ideal for eco-conscious buyers.
If a newer model isn’t in your budget, the 2017-2019 hybrids are also highly recommended due to their improved reliability and fewer reported problems compared to the first-generation hybrid units. These hybrids also marked improved refinement in the drivetrain and were well-received among owners looking for improved fuel efficiency without sacrificing space. Always consider the battery warranty and maintenance history when buying a used hybrid.
6. What years introduced major updates or redesigns in the Highlander lineup?
Major updates and redesigns in the Highlander lineup typically occur every few years, with 2008, 2014, and 2020 serving as key milestones. The 2008 model introduced minor facelifts and revised suspension settings, while the 2014 redesign showcased new styling, improved safety features, and a more user-friendly interior. However, the most transformative revamp came with the 2020 model year, built on Toyota’s TNGA-K architecture.
This platform brought substantial improvements in handling, ride comfort, and crash safety, and enabled the integration of the latest technology across the lineup. The 2020 redesign also allowed for the inclusion of the more powerful and fuel-efficient hybrid powertrain. Additionally, for the 2022 model year, Toyota rolled out a minor facelift along with the introduction of a standard digital touchscreen, enhancing the SUV’s tech appeal.
7. How do I determine if a specific Highlander model year is right for me?
To determine if a specific Highlander model year is right for you, assess your needs in terms of budget, desired technology, fuel efficiency, and interior space. Research common issues from known model years, using online forums, owner reviews, and reliability ratings from trusted sources such as J.D. Power or Consumer Reports. It’s also wise to look into recalls and service bulletins from Toyota for each model year you’re considering.
After narrowing down your list, test drive multiple years and compare them based on ride quality, cargo capacity, third-row accessibility, and overall comfort. Additionally, speak to current owners or dealerships to verify service costs and dependability records. Finally, have any used model inspected by a qualified mechanic and request maintenance documentation. This process will help ensure the model year you choose aligns perfectly with your lifestyle and driving expectations.