The Toyota Highlander Hybrid has long been praised as a versatile, fuel-efficient, and family-friendly SUV. With a rich history spanning multiple generations, it’s essential to understand which model year offers the best value and experience for potential buyers. If you’re in the market for a used (or new) Toyota Highlander Hybrid, deciding the best year to buy involves evaluating several key aspects: reliability, technological advancements, fuel efficiency, safety features, and overall resale value.
In this in-depth article, we explore the best year to buy a Toyota Highlander Hybrid, considering multiple generations and reviewing key upgrades, common complaints, and performance data over the years.
Overview of the Toyota Highlander Hybrid Generations
To accurately determine the best year to buy, it’s helpful to start by breaking the Highlander Hybrid into its generations:
First Generation (2006–2007)
Toyota introduced the Highlander Hybrid in 2006 as part of a growing movement toward hybrid family SUVs. It featured a 3.3L V6 engine paired with an electric motor, producing a combined 270 horsepower. While praised for its fuel economy (26 mpg city), it was also criticized for being overpriced and underwhelming in acceleration.
Second Generation (2008–2013)
This generation continued with minimal changes. However, 2008 saw a slight price reduction and some trim upgrades. By 2009, Bluetooth and a rearview camera became available, improving tech features significantly.
Third Generation (2014–2020)
Toyota redesigned the Highlander inside and out for this generation. The hybrid version returned in 2017 with a 3.5L V6 Atkinson-cycle engine mated to an electric motor. Fuel efficiency improved to around 29–30 mpg city, and tech features included Apple CarPlay by 2020.
Fourth Generation (2021–Present)
The 2021 Highlander Hybrid received a complete redesign. It included a more modern hybrid powertrain (2.5L inline-four) and improved fuel economy (34 mpg city). Enhanced safety, a roomier interior, and the latest Toyota Safety Sense made this model highly desirable.
Evaluating the Best Year to Buy: Criteria
To identify the best year to buy a Toyota Highlander Hybrid, consider these critical factors:
- Reliability: How well the model years have performed over time
- Technological Features: Infotainment, connectivity, and safety systems
- Fuel Efficiency: Real-world performance and cost-effectiveness
- Resale Value: How well the model retains value over time
- Ownership Cost: Maintenance, insurance, and repair costs
Top Contenders: Breaking Down the Model Years
Now that we’ve outlined the generations and the criteria, let’s explore specific years that stand out for their value and performance.
2017 Toyota Highlander Hybrid
The 2017 model year marked the return of the Hybrid version in the third generation. Key features included:
- Reintroduced Toyota Hybrid Synergy Drive with improved fuel economy
- 5-star NHTSA safety rating
- Updated infotainment system with Apple CarPlay (optional in later models)
- Spacious 3-row seating with modern styling
This year is often cited as a good compromise between cost and performance. With many now having reasonable mileage and pricing, the 2017 model is a popular best year to buy for budget-conscious buyers.
2019 Toyota Highlander Hybrid
By 2019, Toyota had enhanced several critical aspects of the Highlander Hybrid. Highlights include:
- Optional premium tech features (e.g., JBL audio, navigation, panoramic camera)
- Improved fuel economy over previous models
- Refined ride quality and all-wheel drive availability
- Strong reliability score from Consumer Reports
The 2019 model year delivered reliability, better features, and strong residual values. Buyers searching for a pre-owned hybrid SUV with premium features and dependability often consider 2019 one of the best purchases.
2021 Toyota Highlander Hybrid
The fourth-generation redesign in 2021 brought a major overhaul, making it a strong contender for the best year to buy. Key upgrades include:
- Significant mileage gain—34 mpg city
- Bold new design language, including a sleeker, more aerodynamic body
- New Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ suite (Standard across all trims)
- Revised infotainment with 8- or 12.3-inch screen depending on trim
- More spacious interior and third-row room
While the 2021 model may cost more initially, its modern design, safety features, and fuel efficiency make it appealing for both buyers and lessees.
Toyota Highlander Hybrid Engine and Performance Comparison
It’s important to compare engine generations across model years to better determine the best year to buy. Here’s an overview of key drivetrains:
| Year | Engine | Combined MPG | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2006–2007 | 3.3L V6 Hybrid | 26 mpg | First-gen hybrid SUV by Toyota |
| 2017–2020 | 3.5L V6 Hybrid | 27–30 mpg | Improved hybrid technology; standard safety systems added |
| 2021–2024 | 2.5L 4-cylinder Hybrid + eCVT | 34 mpg | All-new architecture; best in class fuel economy |
The 2021 redesign’s hybrid system proves to be a game changer. The combination of Toyota’s hybrid efficiency plus updated aerodynamics and electronics sets a higher standard than past generations.
Safety and Technology Trends Over Model Years
Toyota Safety Sense (TSS) significantly affects the best year to buy.
2007–2016: Limited Advanced Safety
For many years, the Highlander Hybrid lacked standard advanced safety features. While a rearview camera became standard in 2009, forward collision warning, lane departure alerts, and blind spot monitoring didn’t appear across the model range until the third generation around 2018–2019.
2017–2020: Gradual Adoption of TSS
In 2017, Toyota began integrating the original Toyota Safety Sense package. This included:
- Pre-Collision System
- Dynamic Radar Cruise Control
- Lane Departure Alert
- Automatic High Beams
By 2020, almost all trims included upgraded versions of TSS, making the later third-gen models vastly safer than older ones.
2021–2024: Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+
The 2021 model came standard with Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+, which added:
- Improved Pedestrian Detection
- Enhanced Lane Tracing Assist (steers the vehicle to stay centered)
- Larger radar coverage area for adaptive cruise control
- Proactive driving assistance in heavy traffic scenarios
Buyers who prioritize safety and value advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) should consider 2021 or later models.
Ownership Cost and Maintenance: Long-Term Reliability
Fuel efficiency, cost of ownership, and maintenance are critical when determining the best year to buy.
Hybrid System Longevity
Toyota’s hybrid systems are known to last well into 200,000 miles if regularly maintained. Third-generation models (e.g., 2017–2020) have already proven moderately reliable across forums and independent research groups.
Repair and Maintenance Costs
J.D. Power and the RepairPal database consistently rank Toyota vehicles as reliable. For example:
- Average Annual Repair Cost for Toyota Highlander Hybrid: $474
- Frequency of Unplanned Repairs: Low compared to competitors
The 2019 model year is often cited as the peak of reliability in third-gen versions, while 2021 models offer more advanced components but with less data collected on long-term durability.
Resale Value (Kelley Blue Book Data)
| Year | Resale Value (after 5 years, %) | Fuel Savings per Year (Approx.) |
|——|——————————-|———————————|
| 2019 | 57–60% | $1,200 |
| 2020 | 55–58% | $1,200 |
| 2021 | 59–62% | $1,600 |
| 2022 | 60–63% | $1,600–$1,800 |
Note that 2021 and 2022 models have strong fuel efficiency but higher asking prices. However, they also tend to hold their value better over time, making them great investments.
2021 vs. 2022 Toyota Highlander Hybrid: The Ultimate Comparison
While both the 2021 and 2022 Highlander Hybrids are excellent choices, a closer look helps identify which is the best year to buy:
Design and Features
Both years share the same platform, aerodynamic design, and hybrid engine. However, 2022 models came with more standard tech across trims, like advanced interior materials and digital options.
Pricing
The 2021 model was introduced with a fresh design but limited supply, leading to higher MSRP. Buyers may be able to find 2021 models at a lower cost than their 2022 counterparts due to depreciation.
Technology Additions
2022 models often include wireless Apple CarPlay and improved app integrations. While not deal-breakers, these are bonuses for those who value seamless connectivity.
Conclusion
Both 2021 and 2022 offer high fuel efficiency, premium features, and strong safety ratings. However, for the best value, 2021 stands out due to slightly lower prices and near-identical features.
Best Used vs. New Highlander Hybrid: Which Makes More Sense?
The best year to buy a Toyota Highlander Hybrid can be determined by whether you’re purchasing used or new. Here’s a breakdown:
New Highlander Hybrid (2024, 2023, or 2022 Models)
- Benefit from the latest tech and maximum depreciation control
- More confidence in reliability metrics (for 2022 and 2023)
- Higher initial cost and interest rates can affect overall value
Used Highlander Hybrid (2019–2021 Models)
- Better pricing point, with good residual value
- May have more depreciation, but less upfront cost
- For budget-conscious buyers, models between 2019–2021 offer an ideal mix of reliability and performance
Common Consumer Questions and Insightful Answers
Do Older Models Offer Comparable Fuel Efficiency?
Although third-gen models (2017–2020) offer good fuel efficiency (around 28–30 mpg), they are not as powerful or efficient as the fourth-gen (2021–2024) models, which achieve up to 36 mpg combined in some test cycles.
Are Repairs Costly in Hybrid SUVs?
The short answer is no — Toyota’s hybrid systems are robust. Hybrid components are generally durable and only incur high costs in unusual circumstances like battery failure during accidents.
Which Trim is the Best Value?
The XLE and LE trims generally offer a balance of luxury, tech, and practicality. For more features without breaking the bank, these trims are often ideal.
Final Recommendation: What Is the Best Year to Buy?
Based on reliability data, fuel efficiency, maintenance cost, and ownership satisfaction reported by real owners and independent platforms like Edmunds, Kelley Blue Book, and Consumer Reports:
2021 Toyota Highlander Hybrid is the best year to buy overall, especially if you’re purchasing new or with a moderate budget looking for a well-balanced, safe, and highly fuel-efficient family SUV. It features the most advanced safety systems and a hybrid system with industry-leading mileage.
For buyers on tighter budgets: The 2019 Toyota Highlander Hybrid is an excellent used option. It offers a tested balance of reliability, good fuel economy (up to 30 mpg), and tech modern enough to keep your family entertained and protected.
If you’re seeking exceptional resale value and the option to pass the vehicle on to another family member or sell quickly, consider a 2021–2022 model as a strong investment.
Conclusion
Choosing the best year to buy a Toyota Highlander Hybrid means carefully balancing price, performance, features, and individual preferences. While third-generation models like the 2019 are ideal for many budgets, the redesigned 2021 model offers unmatched fuel efficiency, technology, and safety. Whether you go used or new, the Toyota Highlander Hybrid remains one of the most dependable and efficient midsize family SUVs available today.
When shopping for your next SUV, don’t forget to evaluate individual vehicle history, service records, and overall condition. Ultimately, with the right research and test-driving, any well-maintained Highlander Hybrid can serve your family with dignity for many years.
Why is 2021 considered a top year for buying a Toyota Highlander Hybrid?
The 2021 Toyota Highlander Hybrid received widespread praise due to its full redesign that year, which included a more modern, dynamic exterior design and a significantly upgraded interior. The vehicle also introduced a more powerful hybrid powertrain compared to earlier models, offering better fuel efficiency and a smoother driving experience. Its suite of standard Toyota Safety Sense features was expanded, enhancing its appeal to safety-conscious buyers.
Additionally, 2021 marked the debut of a three-row layout that offered more passenger and cargo space than previous generations. This improved flexibility helped families and active lifestyles by accommodating more people and gear comfortably. With better performance, improved safety, and a refined design, the 2021 model offers an optimal blend of features, making it a standout choice for buyers seeking value and reliability.
Are there any significant differences between the 2020 and 2021 Toyota Highlander Hybrid?
Yes, the biggest difference between the 2020 and 2021 Toyota Highlander Hybrid is that 2021 was a complete redesign year. This introduced a new platform, the TNGA-K architecture, which enhanced the vehicle’s handling, ride quality, and overall safety. The exterior styling became more aggressive and modern, departing from the more conservative look of the 2020 model.
Inside, the 2021 version offered a more spacious and up-to-date interior with upgraded materials and a more driver-focused dashboard layout. The infotainment system was also updated, featuring larger touchscreen options and better integration with smartphone apps. Since the redesign brought significant upgrades across the board, 2021 is often preferred over the 2020 model, which lacks these improvements.
Is the 2023 Toyota Highlander Hybrid worth the investment?
The 2023 Toyota Highlander Hybrid is a strong choice for buyers looking for the latest features and technology, as it builds upon the strengths of the redesigned model line. With enhancements in fuel efficiency, safety, and available tech like a digital dashboard and advanced infotainment system, the 2023 model provides a cutting-edge experience. It also benefits from improvements in hybrid battery longevity and cabin quietness.
However, the latest model does come at a higher price point, both for new and used car buyers. For many, the incremental upgrades may not justify the extra cost compared to earlier model years like 2021 or even 2022. That said, if you’re looking to keep your vehicle for a long time and want the most up-to-date tech, warranty coverage, and customization options, the 2023 Toyota Highlander Hybrid is worth serious consideration.
Which year of the Toyota Highlander Hybrid has the best reliability record?
The 2021 model year is often cited as one of the most reliable iterations of the Toyota Highlander Hybrid, benefiting from being a redesign year that incorporated lessons learned from previous models. Toyota’s historical reliability, combined with early feedback on the redesigned Highlander, suggests that 2021 and 2022 vehicles have strong long-term durability. Owners and experts have reported fewer mechanical issues reported for these years compared to the pre-redesign models.
With Toyota’s renowned reputation for durable hybrids and the incorporation of more refined components in the second half of the model’s latest generation, 2021 stands out as a solid foundation for reliability. Consumer Reports and other sources often highlight early model years after a redesign—in this case, 2021—as the most dependable, since they’ve benefited from improvements while avoiding potential issues that can appear in the latest models due to newly introduced technologies.
What should buyers watch for when purchasing a used Toyota Highlander Hybrid?
When purchasing a used Toyota Highlander Hybrid, it’s essential to look at the vehicle’s service history, accident reports, and maintenance records. This is especially important for pre-2021 models, which had some known issues like third-row seating discomfort and underwhelming acceleration. Checking whether the previous owner kept up with hybrid-specific maintenance, like battery cooling system flushes, can provide insight into the car’s condition.
Also, be cautious of high-mileage models, as even Toyota hybrids can show signs of wear over time. It’s crucial to have the hybrid battery system inspected by a qualified technician, as replacement costs can be high if the battery fails after the warranty expires. Certified pre-owned vehicles are often the safest route, as they come with extended warranties and are subjected to more rigorous inspections than private-party vehicles.
How does the Toyota Highlander Hybrid compare to similar hybrid SUVs?
The Toyota Highlander Hybrid holds its own against competitors like the Honda Pilot Hybrid and the Ford Explorer Hybrid, especially in terms of reliability and fuel efficiency. Its hybrid powertrain delivers consistent performance with an EPA-estimated 36 mpg in the city, making it one of the more efficient large hybrid SUVs on the market. Toyota’s long-standing expertise in hybrid technology also adds to the Highlander Hybrid’s appeal over newer or less refined hybrid systems in competing models.
Additionally, the Highlander Hybrid benefits from a more intuitive infotainment system, ample seating for up to eight passengers, and a lower starting price than some rival models. While the Honda Pilot offers a more engaging driving experience, it can’t match the Highlander’s fuel economy. Overall, the Highlander Hybrid strikes a balance between family-friendly features, efficiency, and long-term dependability, making it a top contender in its class.
Why is the Toyota Highlander Hybrid a good vehicle for families?
The Toyota Highlander Hybrid is ideal for families due to its spacious interior, offering seating for up to eight passengers with flexible seating configurations. The third-row in the 2021 and later models is notably more usable for adults compared to previous versions, enhancing its appeal for bigger families or carpool situations. Safety is also a priority, with the inclusion of Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ as standard, which includes features like adaptive cruise control, lane departure alert, and automatic emergency braking.
Moreover, the hybrid powertrain’s fuel efficiency helps reduce frequent trips to the gas station, which can be particularly beneficial for families who make a lot of weekend trips or long commutes. The availability of hands-free tailgates, rear-seat entertainment systems, and multiple USB ports further enhances its practicality for family use. With a strong blend of space, safety, and efficiency, the Toyota Highlander Hybrid stands out as a thoughtful and functional option for growing families.