The Toyota GT86 (also known as the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S in some markets) is a car that evokes passion. Its sleek lines, rear-wheel-drive configuration, and focus on driving experience make it a desirable vehicle for enthusiasts. But is it a sensible choice for a first car, particularly for a new or inexperienced driver? The answer, as with most things in life, is nuanced. Let’s delve into the pros and cons to help you make an informed decision.
The Allure of the GT86: Why It’s So Appealing
The GT86 occupies a unique space in the automotive market. It’s relatively affordable (especially used), sports car-esque in appearance, and prioritizes driving pleasure over outright power.
Rear-Wheel Drive Fun
The most significant draw for many is the rear-wheel-drive (RWD) configuration. This offers a completely different driving dynamic compared to the more common front-wheel-drive (FWD) cars. RWD allows for more precise steering and a playful, engaging experience, especially when cornering. It’s the foundation for learning proper car control techniques.
Balanced Handling
The GT86 boasts excellent weight distribution. This translates to predictable and responsive handling, making it a forgiving platform for learning the basics of performance driving. It’s nimble and feels light on its feet.
Affordable Sports Car Entry
Unlike many sports cars that carry hefty price tags, the GT86 provides an accessible entry point for those seeking an engaging driving experience without breaking the bank. Its relatively low cost of entry, especially on the used market, makes it an attractive option for younger drivers.
Looks That Kill (But Not Really)
Let’s be honest, the GT86 looks good. Its sporty coupe silhouette and aggressive styling turn heads. For many young drivers, owning a car that looks cool is a definite plus.
The Downsides: Challenges and Considerations
Despite its allure, the GT86 presents challenges, particularly for novice drivers. It’s essential to understand these potential drawbacks before committing.
Rear-Wheel Drive Demands Respect
That RWD magic can quickly turn into a handful in the wrong hands. Unlike FWD cars, which tend to understeer (plowing straight even when the wheel is turned), RWD cars can oversteer (the rear of the car swings out). This requires a different set of skills and reactions to control. Inexperienced drivers may find themselves struggling to maintain control in slippery conditions or during aggressive maneuvers. Proper training and a respect for the car’s limits are crucial.
Power Delivery: Not Always Smooth
The GT86’s engine, while generally reliable, has a notorious “torque dip” in the mid-range. This means there’s a noticeable drop in power and torque around 3,000-4,000 RPM. This can make the car feel sluggish at times and require careful gear selection to maintain momentum. While some find it characterful, it can be frustrating for new drivers who are still learning to anticipate and manage engine power.
Practicality: It’s a Coupe
The GT86 is a coupe, meaning it has two doors and a relatively small interior. Rear seats are cramped and best suited for children or luggage. Cargo space is limited. If you regularly need to transport passengers or bulky items, the GT86 might not be the most practical choice.
Running Costs: More Than a Corolla
While the initial purchase price might be appealing, running costs should be considered. Sports cars often require premium fuel. Insurance premiums can be higher, especially for young drivers. Maintenance and repairs can also be more expensive than for a more mainstream vehicle. Budgeting for these additional expenses is essential.
Winter Driving: A Challenge
Unless equipped with proper winter tires, the GT86 can be a handful in snow or ice. The RWD configuration and lack of weight over the rear wheels make it prone to losing traction. Winter tires are a must for driving in snowy conditions. Even with winter tires, extra caution and experience are required.
Assessing Your Skills and Needs
Before deciding if a GT86 is right for you, honestly assess your driving skills, needs, and priorities.
Driving Experience
Are you a brand new driver with limited experience behind the wheel? Or have you had some practice through driver’s education or other means? The less experience you have, the steeper the learning curve will be with a GT86.
Driving Environment
Where will you be driving the car most often? City streets? Highways? Rural roads? Snowy or icy conditions? The GT86 is more suited to dry pavement and open roads than stop-and-go traffic or challenging weather.
Driving Style
Are you a cautious and responsible driver, or do you tend to be more aggressive and impulsive? The GT86 rewards smooth and precise driving, but it can also be unforgiving if pushed too hard without proper skill.
Practical Needs
Do you need a car for daily commuting, transporting passengers, or carrying cargo? Or is it primarily for recreational driving and occasional trips? The GT86 is less practical than a sedan or hatchback.
Budget
Can you afford the purchase price, insurance, fuel, maintenance, and potential repairs? Don’t stretch your budget too thin, as unexpected expenses can quickly arise.
Making an Informed Decision
So, is the GT86 a good first car? Here’s a summary to guide your decision:
Reasons Why It Could Be a Good Choice:
- Engaging driving experience: The RWD configuration and balanced handling provide a fun and rewarding driving experience.
- Learning opportunity: The GT86 can be a great platform for learning proper car control techniques.
- Affordable sports car: It offers an accessible entry point into the world of sports cars.
- Stylish looks: Its sporty design makes it a head-turner.
Reasons Why It Might Not Be a Good Choice:
- RWD can be challenging: Requires more skill and attention, especially in slippery conditions.
- Torque dip: Can feel sluggish at times.
- Limited practicality: Small interior and cargo space.
- Higher running costs: Insurance, fuel, and maintenance can be more expensive.
- Difficult in winter: Requires winter tires and extra caution.
The Verdict: It Depends
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not a GT86 is a good first car depends on your individual circumstances. If you are a responsible and cautious driver with a genuine interest in learning car control, and you understand the potential challenges, the GT86 can be a rewarding first car. However, if you are a new driver with limited experience, live in an area with harsh weather, or need a practical and affordable vehicle, a different car might be a better choice.
Consider these recommendations:
- Take a driving course: If you’re set on a GT86, invest in a performance driving course to learn how to handle a RWD car safely.
- Start slow: Don’t push the car to its limits until you are comfortable with its handling characteristics.
- Drive in a safe environment: Practice car control skills in a controlled environment, such as a racetrack or autocross course.
- Consider a test drive: Spend some time behind the wheel of a GT86 to see if it feels like the right fit for you.
Alternatives to Consider
If you’re unsure about the GT86, consider these alternatives that offer similar driving dynamics with potentially fewer drawbacks:
- Mazda MX-5 Miata: A lightweight and agile roadster with excellent handling.
- Volkswagen GTI: A sporty hatchback with a fun-to-drive character and more practicality.
- Ford Fiesta ST: A small and nimble hatchback with a powerful engine.
- Honda Civic Si: A sporty sedan with a refined driving experience and good reliability.
Choosing your first car is a significant decision. Take your time, do your research, and make an informed choice that aligns with your skills, needs, and budget. Remember, the most important thing is to drive safely and responsibly.
Is a GT86/BRZ practical for everyday use as a first car?
The GT86/BRZ offers limited practicality due to its 2+2 seating configuration, where the rear seats are best suited for small children or storage. The trunk space is also relatively small, making it challenging to transport large items like luggage for extended trips. While not impossible, everyday tasks like grocery shopping or transporting friends might require some strategic planning.
However, if practicality isn’t your top priority and you primarily need a car for commuting or weekend drives, the GT86/BRZ can suffice. Its compact size makes it easy to maneuver in city traffic and park in tight spaces. Plus, the fun driving experience can make even mundane trips more enjoyable. Just be prepared to compromise on cargo space and passenger comfort.
Are GT86/BRZs expensive to maintain as a first car?
The GT86/BRZ is generally considered to be relatively reliable, leading to lower maintenance costs compared to some other sports cars. Routine maintenance, such as oil changes and tire rotations, are fairly standard and won’t break the bank. The availability of aftermarket parts can also help to keep repair costs down.
However, keep in mind that as a sports car, it may be driven more aggressively, potentially leading to increased wear and tear on components like brakes and tires. Also, modifications and performance upgrades, which are common among GT86/BRZ owners, can significantly increase maintenance expenses. Thoroughly inspecting a used model and sticking to a regular maintenance schedule are crucial for minimizing unexpected repair bills.
How safe are GT86/BRZs for new drivers?
The GT86/BRZ offers a decent level of safety features, including standard airbags, anti-lock brakes, and stability control. These systems can help new drivers maintain control in challenging situations. However, it’s important to note that these cars are rear-wheel drive, which can be less forgiving than front-wheel drive in slippery conditions like rain or snow.
Furthermore, the focus on driving experience means some of the newer driver-assistance technologies, like lane departure warning or automatic emergency braking, may not be available, particularly on older models. New drivers should prioritize learning proper driving techniques and developing good habits rather than relying solely on safety features. Practice in a safe environment is highly recommended.
Is the GT86/BRZ a good choice for learning to drive a manual transmission?
The GT86/BRZ is widely regarded as an excellent car for learning to drive a manual transmission. The clutch is relatively forgiving, and the shifter has a precise and satisfying feel. The car also provides good feedback, making it easier to understand how the engine and transmission are working together. Its manageable power output reduces the risk of accidental wheelspin or stalls.
While learning any manual transmission takes practice, the GT86/BRZ’s user-friendly design can make the process smoother and more enjoyable. The car’s responsiveness encourages drivers to pay attention to their inputs and develop good habits. Many driving instructors specifically recommend this car for learning stick shift.
What are the potential insurance costs for a GT86/BRZ as a first car?
Insurance costs for a GT86/BRZ can be significantly higher compared to more practical and less sporty vehicles. Insurers often view sports cars as higher risk due to their performance capabilities and the potential for reckless driving. This can result in substantially higher premiums, especially for young and inexperienced drivers.
Several factors influence insurance rates, including age, driving record, location, and the specific insurance company. It’s essential to shop around and compare quotes from multiple insurers before making a decision. Consider increasing the deductible to lower the premium, but be sure you can afford to pay the deductible in the event of an accident. Talking to an insurance agent is always advised.
How well does the GT86/BRZ handle in different weather conditions?
The GT86/BRZ, being a rear-wheel-drive sports car, can be challenging to drive in adverse weather conditions like rain or snow. The lack of weight over the rear wheels can make it prone to losing traction, especially when accelerating or braking aggressively. This requires a skilled and cautious driver, especially in slippery conditions.
Proper tires are crucial for improving handling in different weather conditions. Switching to winter tires during colder months can significantly enhance grip and control on snow and ice. Additionally, using a light throttle and practicing smooth steering inputs can help prevent the car from losing control. It’s important to gain experience in a safe environment before attempting to drive the GT86/BRZ in challenging weather.
What alternatives should I consider if a GT86/BRZ isn’t suitable as a first car?
If the GT86/BRZ proves impractical or too expensive, several alternatives offer a balance of affordability, practicality, and fun. Options like the Mazda MX-5 Miata provide a similar sporty driving experience in a more compact and arguably more accessible package. Front-wheel-drive hatchbacks like the Honda Civic Si or Volkswagen GTI also provide sporty handling with increased practicality.
Another alternative is to consider a slightly older, more affordable sports car like a used Mazda RX-8 or a Nissan 350Z. However, be mindful of potential maintenance costs associated with older vehicles. Ultimately, the best alternative depends on your individual needs, priorities, and budget. Thorough research and test driving are essential for finding the right fit.